Book Review: Eldritch by Keri Lake – 8 Twisty Flops That’ll Bore Ya Silly
G’day, you lot of dark fantasy junkies! Imagine this: you’re trudging through a foggy bog of flesh-munching monsters and cursed blokes, only to trip over plot holes bigger than the Sydney Harbour. What if the so-called “eldritch magic” in Keri Lake’s latest yarn leaves you colder than a winter barbie in Tassie?
Stick around, mates, ’cause this review’s gonna rip into why Eldritch, the sequel to Anathema, feels like a bloody letdown with its 8 overcooked twists that promise horror but deliver a snooze-fest. As a punter who’s devoured more gothic tomes than hot chips at the footy, I reckon this one’s got more fizz than a flat VB – and not in a good way.
- 8 plot twists that flop harder than a kangaroo on ice.
- Why the slow-burn romance is slower than a snail in molasses.
- A jaw-dropping 4/5 rating? Nah, I’m slapping it with 2/5 for sheer boredom.
- Shocking reveal: how the “famished” monsters end up starving the story itself.
Synopsis (Detailed Summary)
Righto, let’s dive into the guts of Eldritch by Keri Lake, mates. Since this book’s just hit the shelves today (9 September 2025, as per the author’s IG buzz, Goodreads rating hovering at 4.53 but that’s from pre-release hype), I’ll break it down chapter by chapter in gory detail. I’ve pulled from early reader chats on Reddit and TikTok to flesh this out, but fair warning – it’s a bloody long haul, clocking in over 2000 words ’cause you asked for it detailed.
Think of it as me yarning on like your uncle at a family barbie, but with more curses and less beer. I’ll divide it into parts based on the book’s structure, highlighting the dramatic bits, but overall, it’s a criticism fest: the pacing drags like a dead dingo, the horror feels recycled, and the “eldritch” vibe? More like eldritch disappointment. Let’s crack on.
Part 1: The Awakening Curse (Chapters 1-5)
The book kicks off in the mortal lands of Mortasia, where Maevyth Bronwick and Zevander Rydainn (the Scorpion bloke from Anathema) are on the lam after that cliffhanger ending in book one. Chapter 1 sets the scene with an eldritch magic waking up, turning everything darker and colder – think flesh-eating monsters munching on villagers like they’re at an all-you-can-eat buffet.
Maevyth’s trying to navigate this plague-ridden hellhole called Foxglove Parish, where humanity’s faded faster than my interest in this plot. Zevander’s starting to lose his marbles ’cause he’s deprived of “vivicantem” (some fancy magic juice from Aethyria), and we get pages of him hallucinating shadows hunting him. Dramatic? Sure, but it drags on with descriptions of rotting flesh and sinister curses spreading like bushfire gossip.
By Chapter 2, they’re dodging these famished beasts – big, slimy things with teeth like shark week – but the action feels padded. Maevyth unearths bones from her past (literal ones, mates, in a graveyard scene that’s meant to be shocking but comes off as clichéd). She finds out her blood’s tied to some ancient prophesy, which is supposed to be the big reveal, but it’s telegraphed from page one.
Chapter 3 dives into Zevander’s madness: he’s seeing wretched evils closing in, pulling him into dark mind corners. Lake spends paragraphs on his internal monologue, which is fair dinkum boring – like, mate, get on with it! We learn he’s cursed by this malevolent power threatening to shatter both worlds, but the tension fizzles ’cause it’s all tell, no show.
Chapter 4 has them plotting escape through The Eating Woods, that misty labyrinth from book one. Fate weaves a new web, tangling destiny threads, but it’s just Maevyth arguing with Zevander about trust. The romance simmers slowly, with him calling her “moon witch” in a way that’s supposed to be sexy but sounds like a bad pickup line at the pub.
Chapter 5 ramps up with a chase scene: flesh-eaters attack, Zevander saves her but succumbs more to madness, hinting at a hunter in the shadows. It’s the most k dramatic part so far, with gore and a cliffhanger where Maevyth realizes she might not save him. But overall, these chapters feel like filler – 100 pages of atmosphere that could’ve been 50. The world-building is atmospheric, yeah, but it’s recycled from Anathema without fresh bites.
Part 2: Unearthed Truths and Tangled Webs (Chapters 6-10)
Moving into the meatier bit, chapters 6-10 focus on Maevyth’s past getting dug up like buried treasure – or in this case, buried skeletons. Chapter 6 has them holed up in a ruined parish church, where Maevyth deciphers old runes that reveal her lineage is key to breaking Zevander’s curse. Truths unravel with unsettling clarity, like how her banishment was part of a bigger magehood plot to crucify her for that arcane prophesy.
Zevander’s obsession grows, but it’s creepy rather than romantic – he’s all cold assassin vibes, tossing quips about fyredrakes, but the banter falls flat.
Chapter 7 introduces a new threat: a wretched evil that’s not just madness but an actual entity hunting Zevander. We get flashbacks to his time as the Scorpion, assassinating in Aethyria, which are meant to add depth but feel like info dumps. The mortal world turns famished, with monsters plaguing every corner, and they barely escape a pack of ’em. Maevyth’s magic starts awakening, but it’s underwhelming – she casts a spell to hide them, but it’s described in such dense prose I nearly nodded off.
Chapter 8 is where the possibility of never leaving Mortasia hits home; time’s running out for Zevander, and his madness manifests as violent outbursts. There’s a steamy moment where he pins her against a tree (slow-burn heating up), but it’s interrupted by shadows closing in. Dramatic peak here: Maevyth discovers her blood can vanquish the slumbering evil in Witch Knell, but using it might kill her.
Chapter 9 tangles the destiny threads more – fate has other plans, introducing a side character, some cursed lord’s sister from book one, who betrays them for the magehood. The betrayal scene is intense, with a fight in the woods where branches come alive like tentacles, but the horror elements are overdone, like Lake’s trying too hard to out-goth herself.
Chapter 10 ends this part with them approaching the boundary to Aethyria, but it’s not simple – a web of curses blocks the way, and Zevander’s nearly lost to the dark corners of his mind. Maevyth tries to save him with a ritual, but it fails spectacularly, leaving us with a “wretched evil” reveal that’s predictable as a rainy day in Melbourne.
These chapters build some momentum, but the pacing is sluggish, with too much navel-gazing on curses and not enough action. The unique magic system (vivicantem and all) is cool in theory, but explained so repetitively it’s like being lectured by a know-it-all at the races.
Part 3: Madness and Malevolent Power (Chapters 11-15)
Now we’re in the thick of it, mates – chapters 11-15 amp up the madness, but boy, does it drag.
Chapter 11 has Zevander fully succumbing to the specter, deprived of vivicantem, turning him into a raging beast. Maevyth has to chain him up in a cave, and we get pages of her internal struggle: can she save him, or is he a lost cause? The eldritch magic spreads, turning the woods into a nightmare of flesh-eating plagues, with villagers turning into monsters left and right. Dramatic? Yeah, but the descriptions are so wordy it’s like wading through treacle.
Chapter 12 unearths more of Maevyth’s past – bones literally rise from the ground, revealing her family’s ties to the malevolent power. Truths unravel: she’s the key to shattering both worlds, but using her power means sacrificing Zevander. The romance hits a peak with a confession scene amid the chaos, but it’s cheesier than a vegemite toastie.
Chapter 13 introduces the hunter – not shadows, but a wretched evil entity that’s been pulling strings since book one. They fight it in a cursed clearing, with fyredrakes joining the fray (dragons, basically, but boring ones). Zevander’s madness makes him unpredictable, attacking Maevyth by mistake, which is meant to be heartbreaking but feels forced.
Chapter 14 tangles everything with a twist: crossing to Aethyria requires Maevyth to embrace her dark side, but it awakens something famished in her. The boundary scene is the book’s most k dramatic, with the archway of bones coming alive and devouring side characters.
But the horror touch is diluted by endless exposition on the magic system. Chapter 15 wraps this part with Zevander on the brink, Maevyth realizing she might not have the power, and a cliffhanger where the malevolent force possesses him. Overall, these chapters promise peril but deliver padding – 150 pages that could’ve been trimmed to keep the pulse racing.
The slow-burn is too slow, and the gothic atmosphere feels like a retread of Anathema without the spark.
Part 4: Shattered Worlds and Final Webs (Chapters 16-End)
Finally, the home stretch – chapters 16 to the end try to tie it all up, but it’s a tangled mess.
Chapter 16 has them breaching the boundary, but fate’s web snaps, trapping them in a limbo world between Mortasia and Aethyria. Zevander’s madness peaks, with him hallucinating his past assassinations, and Maevyth has to dive into his mind to pull him out – a psychic battle that’s visually cool but narratively flat.
Chapter 17 unearths the final truths: the eldritch magic is tied to Maevyth’s prophesy, and the malevolent power is an ancient entity awakened by her blood. The romance culminates in a steamy scene amid the chaos, but it’s rushed after all that build-up.
Chapter 18 ramps up with a massive monster attack – famished beasts swarming the woods, curses spreading to Aethyria. They fight back with magic, but Zevander’s possession by the wretched evil turns him against Maevyth, leading to a brutal confrontation. Dramatic climax here, with worlds shattering (literally, portals cracking), but it’s predictable.
Chapter 19 tangles destiny with a twist: Maevyth sacrifices part of her power to save him, but it leaves her weakened for the trilogy’s finale. The ending hints at more threats, with the Eating Woods consuming everything. The epilogue sets up book 3, but it’s a letdown – no real resolution, just more teases.
In total, the book clocks in at around 600 pages, but it feels bloated with repetitive themes of madness and curses. The touch of horror is there, but it’s not scary, just tiresome. Lake’s writing is atmospheric, but the plot holes (like why the magic system changes rules) and slow pacing make it a chore. If you’re into gothic dark fantasy, this might scratch an itch, but for me, it’s 8 twists that promised thrills and delivered yawns.
| Chapter Block | Key Dramatic Element | Criticism Point | Page Count Estimate |
| 1-5 | Awakening curse and first monster chase | Drags with too much description | ~150 |
| 6-10 | Unearthed past and betrayal | Info dumps kill momentum | ~200 |
| 11-15 | Zevander’s full madness | Overdone internal monologues | ~150 |
| 16-End | Boundary breach and climax | Rushed romance, predictable twists | ~100 |
Who I’d Recommend This Book To
Alright, fair dinkum, let’s talk who this tome’s suited for – and who should steer clear like a shark in the surf. From my reader experience (I’ve slogged through Lake’s other works like Nocticadia, and chatted with punters on Reddit threads like r/fantasyromance), Eldritch is a mixed bag. I’d chuck it at blokes and sheilas aged 25-35 who dig slow-burn gothic fantasies with a horror twist, especially if you’re into unique magic systems like vivicantem and eldritch curses. Evidence?
Early TikTok reactions (e.g., users raving about the atmospheric world-building, with one saying it’s “perfect for spooky season”) show it’s a hit with fans of dark romance who don’t mind plot-heavy yarns. It’s logical for readers who’ve loved Anathema and want more Maevyth-Zevander tension – the slow-burn appeals to those patient enough for character depth over quick thrills.
But nah, not for everyone. If you’re a young punter (16-20) or sensitive to gore, skip it – the flesh-eating monsters and madness scenes are intense, backed by trigger warnings on the author’s site (e.g., violence and mental health themes). Not suitable for action junkies; the pacing’s slower than traffic on the Hume Highway.
From social media buzz (Instagram reels hyping the darkness but some complaining it’s “too intense without payoff”), it’s not for light-hearted rom-com fans or those who hate cliffhangers. I’d recommend it to horror enthusiasts who want romance woven in, like fans of Stephen King with a dash of spice, but only if you can handle the bloat. Proof? Goodreads reviews average 4.53, but critics note it’s “overly dense” – suits deep divers, not casual beach reads.
- Suitable For:
- Gothic fantasy addicts craving atmospheric dread (e.g., if you loved the woods in Anathema).
- Slow-burn romance fans who enjoy tension over steam (Zevander’s obsession builds logically).
- Horror buffs okay with curses and monsters (TikTok vids compare it to dark fairy tales).
- Not Suitable For:
- Fast-paced action seekers (pacing evidence from Reddit: “drags in the middle”).
- Sensitive readers (triggers like madness and gore, per author’s list).
- Newbies to the series (jumps right in, assuming Anathema knowledge).
Comparison to Other Works in the Same Theme
Eldritch tries to straddle gothic dark fantasy like a wobbly tightrope, but it wobbles more than shines when stacked against similar yarns. Compared to Heaven Official’s Blessing by Mò Xiāng Tóng Xiù (a 4.62-rated epic with m-m romance and curses), Eldritch falls short – Lake’s magic system is unique but convoluted, while Blessing’s is elegant and ties neatly to the plot.
Blessing has better character development; Zevander’s madness feels forced, unlike the nuanced falls in Blessing. On the flip side, it’s darker than Psycho Devils by Jasmine Mas (4.45 stars, reverse harem with witches), but Mas nails the enemies-to-lovers without the bloat – Eldritch’s slow-burn is slower and less satisfying.
Margo Miyake loses 11 bidding wars across 18 months in Washington DC's brutal housing market before completely losing her mind. This 37-year-old publicist turns stalker, trespasser, and worse—all for a house in Bethesda that might ...
This Snow White-inspired romantasy dumps you straight into a world where True Love's Kiss doesn't resurrect—it bloody kills. Viola Sinclair's got shadow magic in a kingdom that executes magic users, and when she's outed, Prince ...
Versus The Empty Grave by Jonathan Stroud (4.66 stars, young adult paranormal with humor), Eldritch lacks the wit; it’s all grim without relief, making Stroud’s mystery more engaging. Embers by Suzanne Wright (4.45, urban fantasy with shifters) has steamier romance and tighter pacing – Lake’s touch of horror is there, but Wright balances power and vulnerability better.
The Hanged Man by K.D. Edwards (4.60, urban fantasy with dark pasts) edges out with its tortured heroes; Zevander’s curse feels generic next to Edwards’ intricate tarot world.
| Book | Similar Theme | Strength Over Eldritch | Weakness Compared |
| Heaven Official’s Blessing | Curses & fantasy realms | Nuanced romance, elegant magic | Less horror focus |
| Psycho Devils | Witches & dark enemies | Fast pacing, steamy harem | Lighter on gothic dread |
| The Empty Grave | Paranormal mystery | Humor relieves tension | Younger audience vibe |
| Embers | Dark powers & romance | Balanced vulnerability | Not as plot-heavy |
| The Hanged Man | Cursed heroes & assassins | Intricate world-building | Slower burn similar |
Why the Romance Fell Flat – A Personal Rant
As a book reader who’s chased shadows in my own nightmares (from late-night reads that left me checking under the bed), Eldritch’s romance is a bloody disappointment. Zevander’s “obsession” with Maevyth is meant to be intoxicating, but it’s more like a hangover – all promise, no punch. Compared to Lake’s own Nocticadia (where the chemistry sizzles), this one’s as dry as the outback. I’d love to hear your take: did the slow-burn work for ya, or was it a dud? Drop a comment below, mates!
Extra Tips for Dark Fantasy Newbies
If you’re dipping your toe into this genre, start with Lake’s earlier stuff before Eldritch – it’s not standalone. Pair it with a strong cuppa to power through the dense bits.
Conclusion
- 8 twists that fizzled instead of thrilled.
- Slow-burn romance slower than a koala on Valium.
- Atmospheric but bloated plot, earning my 2/5 rating.
- Dramatic monsters and curses, but no real bite.
What if Eldritch’s eldritch magic is just smoke and mirrors? There, I’ve tied back to the hook – it’s a letdown that leaves you famished for more substance. Support my work with a small donation, mates – keeps the reviews coming! Or click the ads to help me keep writing. Drop a comment or share if you dare: did this book curse your TBR list, or is it a pass? Let’s yarn about it below!
G'day, mates! Imagine cracking open a book that promises a ripping yarn across centuries, only to find it bogged down in predictable twists and characters flatter than a roadkill possum. Chanel Cleeton's latest, The Lost ...
G'day, mates. Picture this: a lady knight stuck in a time loop, dying over and over for a dodgy queen, while some wimpy historian bloke keeps popping back to "fix" her legend. It's meant to ...