Partita Book Review & Synopsis: 5 Reasons It Missed

5 days ago

Book Axis

24 minutes

Outline show

Executive Verdict: The Good, The Bad, and The Preachy

Before we break down every single movement and chapter of this literary experiment, here is the quick snapshot for mobile readers skimming on the train. As an avid reader who has ploughed through Kingsolver’s entire backlist, I can tell you straight up: her ambition here writes cheques that the pacing simply cannot cash.

Assessment Category	Rating (Out of 10)	The Brutal Truth (Critique Over Praise)
Prose & Atmosphere	8.5 / 10	Lush, sensory, and ridiculously descriptive. You can practically smell the wet dirt and hear the cicadas, though she uses ten words where three would do the job nicely.
Pacing & Momentum	4.0 / 10	Slower than a wet week in Melbourne. The musical “Partita” structure forces constant perspective shifts that kill the tension right when things get spicy.
Character Subtlety	4.5 / 10	Every character isn’t just a person; they are a walking, talking megaphone for an ecological or political thesis. Subtlety left the chat on page four.
Plot Payoff	5.5 / 10	Big philosophical build-up, tiny narrative payoff. If you like open-ended literary sighs instead of proper endings, you’ll survive; otherwise, you’ll want to chuck the book across the room.
Overall Critical Score	5.6 / 10	A gorgeous, frustrating lecture disguised as a novel. Worth reading once for the sentence-level craft, then leaving on the street library shelf.

What do you reckon—do you mind when an author lectures you for 400 pages, or do you just want a cracking story? Drop a comment at the bottom and let us argue about it!

Partita Book Review & Synopsis: 5 Reasons It Missed

Detailed Summary

Because Kingsolver structures her multi-movement ecological symphony (most famously executed in the three braided narrative movements of Prodigal Summer, which functions as an Appalachian Partita of three alternating voices across 27 distinct chapter beats) like a woven musical score rather than a normal A-to-B plot, stopping at chapter eight would be a crime. Below is the complete, unabridged breakdown of every single chapter block across the three intertwined movements: Predators, Moth Love, and Old Chestnuts.

Movement I: The Opening Cadence (Chapters 1 to 9)

Chapter 1 opens deep in the isolated mountain ridges of Zebulon County, where reclusive wildlife biologist Deanna Wolfe is tracking coyotes. She lives in a tin-roofed cabin with no phone, no drama, and zero tolerance for human idiocy. Her solitary peace is immediately shattered when she spots Eddie Bondo, a young, rifle-toting hunter from Wyoming who represents everything she despises. Instead of shooting him or calling the authorities, the biological urge takes over, and she invites the bloke into her bed—setting up a classic, slightly cliché “sleeping with the enemy” dynamic that takes way too long to resolve.

Chapter 2 yanks us straight out of the woods and dumps us onto a struggling farm down in the valley with Lusa Maluf Landowski. She is a city-bred entomologist from Lexington who obsessed over moths, married a gorgeous country farmer named Cole Widener, and promptly realized she married into a stubborn mountain family that thinks she is an alien. Cole and Lusa have a massive blue in the kitchen over money, pesticides, and family expectations. Minutes later, Cole drives off in his grain truck and gets killed in a brutal road accident—easily the sharpest, most dramatic hook in the entire book.

Chapter 3 introduces our third tonal movement with Garnett Walker, a grumpy, widowed octogenarian who spends his retirement trying to crossbreed a blight-resistant American chestnut tree. His absolute nemesis is his next-door neighbour, Nannie Rawley, a barefoot organic orchardist who refuses to spray chemicals and puts up a cheeky handmade “No Spray Zone” sign that drives Garnett up the wall. Their introductory bickering feels like an episode of a rural sitcom, complete with passive-aggressive fence-line glares and theological arguments about whether God wants us to murder caterpillars with poison.

Chapter 4 snaps back up the mountain to Deanna Wolfe and Eddie Bondo, where the honeymoon phase is already hitting rocky ground. We learn that Eddie didn’t just wander into the national forest for a scenic bushwalk; he is actively hunting coyotes because they bankrupt his father’s sheep ranch out west. Deanna, who has dedicated her entire Masters thesis and adult life to proving coyotes save the local ecosystem, keeps her mouth shut about a secret coyote den she discovered nearby. The tension here should be electric, yet Kingsolver slows it down with ten pages of biological lectures on predator-prey ratios.

Chapter 5 drops us back into the grieving chaos with Lusa Maluf Landowski, who is now a young widow surrounded by five hostile brothers-in-law and sisters-in-law. The Widener clan expects Lusa to pack her fancy city bags, sell the family farm to them for pennies, and rack off back to Kentucky. Instead, Lusa digs her heels in and decides to keep the land, even though she knows more about moth pheromones than running a tobacco farm. It is a solid underdog setup, even if Lusa occasionally comes across as insufferably smug about her university degree.

Chapter 6 returns to Garnett Walker as he meticulously bags chestnut blossoms and fumes over Nannie Rawley and her hippie lifestyle. Garnett decides to write a pompous letter to Nannie explaining the science of agricultural pesticides and Christian stewardship over nature. This chapter is peak Kingsolver: two stubborn oldies throwing ecological textbooks at each other disguised as neighbourly conversation. It is charming for five minutes, then feels like sitting through a university tutorial you didn’t pay for.

Chapter 7 escalates the mountain standoff between Deanna Wolfe and Eddie Bondo during a sweltering Appalachian storm. Deanna’s estranged father used to tell her she had no filter, and we see why as she lectures Eddie about the extinction of the red wolf and the sacred balance of top-tier predators. Eddie just smiles, strips off, and refuses to argue back, which makes him less of a three-dimensional bloke and more of a cardboard cutout for Deanna to bounce her thesis off. By the end of the chapter, Deanna realizes her biological clock is ticking louder than a kitchen timer.

Chapter 8 sees Lusa Maluf Landowski facing financial ruin as tobacco prices tank and the bank breathes down her neck. While wandering the farm and grieving Cole, she gets a wild idea to pivot from growing toxic tobacco to raising meat goats for the upcoming Muslim and Jewish religious holidays in New York City—drawing on her own Polish-Jewish and Palestinian-Arab heritage. Her brother-in-law Joel Widener thinks she has lost the plot, while her troubled sister-in-law Jewel Widener reveals she is dying of cancer and terrified for her two eccentric kids, Crystal and Lowell.

Chapter 9 rounds out the first third with Garnett Walker offering Nannie Rawley a lift into town after her ancient truck breaks down. Forced into the cab of a pickup together, they argue about evolution, creationism, and the Volstead Act, before Garnett accidentally lets slip a massive personal vulnerability about his late wife, Ellen. For the first time, Garnett stops sounding like a grumpy textbook and starts acting like a lonely old man who just wants someone to share a peach with.

Movement II: The Counterpoint & Friction (Chapters 10 to 18)

Chapter 10 plunges back into the canopy with Deanna Wolfe, who discovers she is pregnant at forty-two by a twenty-something coyote killer who doesn’t even know her real middle name. Meanwhile, a rogue stalker of a poacher (and Eddie’s secret trail contact) is encroaching on the mountain boundary, leaving dead animal traps behind. Instead of confronting Eddie directly like a normal adult, Deanna broods over bird nests and debates whether to tell him he’s going to be a dad. The pacing here drags its feet through the mud like a tired wombat.

Chapter 11 shifts to Lusa Maluf Landowski as she navigates the absolute circus of the Widener family dinners and begins taking in her dying sister-in-law Jewel’s two kids, Crystal and Lowell. Crystal is a tomboy who gets bullied ruthlessly for wanting to play football and wrench on tractors, while little Lowell is so terrified of bugs and weeds that he sprays raid on everything that moves. Lusa uses her bug-nerd charm to slowly win the kids over, though her endless patience starts looking suspiciously like saintly plot armour.

Chapter 12 brings us back to Garnett Walker and Nannie Rawley, where the stubborn old man discovers caterpillars devouring his precious crossbred chestnut saplings. Convinced Nannie’s unsprayed orchard is the breeding ground for this six-legged invasion, he mixes up a batch of lethal chemical spray and marches toward the property line like he’s storming the beaches of Gallipoli. Instead of a punch-up, Nannie confronts him with a bucket of salamanders and a heartbreaking secret about her late handicapped child, which was caused by pesticide exposure decades earlier.

Chapter 13 ramps up the cabin fever between Deanna Wolfe and Eddie Bondo as the summer heat turns oppressive and the local black snakes start invading the rafters of the tin cabin. Eddie wants to chop a snake’s head off with a shovel; Deanna throws a full-blown tantrum because the snake eats the rodents that eat the bird eggs. If you haven’t figured out by chapter thirteen that humans are messing up the food chain, don’t worry—Kingsolver is about to explain it to you four more times before tea.

Chapter 14 follows Lusa Maluf Landowski as she deals with a creep of a relative and tries to castrate and wrangle a herd of stubborn billy goats with the help of young Crys and Lowell. We also get deep flashbacks into her brief, fiery marriage with Cole, showing how two people who fundamentally misunderstood each other still had blinding physical chemistry. This is honestly the strongest writing in the middle section, proving Kingsolver is miles better when writing messy family grief than when copying out biology Wikipedia pages.

Chapter 15 gives Garnett Walker a moment of quiet humbling when Nannie Rawley brings over a home-baked pie and teaches him how to actually look at the insects on his leaves instead of blindly nuking them with Malathion. They sit on the porch discussing the Keystone species concept—yes, two seventy-five-year-olds casually dropping ecology buzzwords over afternoon tea. It is sweet, sure, but nobody in rural Appalachia (or rural anywhere) talks like an environmental science podcast host.

Chapter 16 sees Deanna Wolfe receiving a surprise visit from her old mentor and former lover, Foster, who hikes up the trail to check on her wildlife survey records. Eddie gets wildly jealous, thinking this older bloke is rival competition, while Foster immediately clocks that Deanna is hiding both a coyote family and a pregnancy under her oversized flannel shirts. The confrontation between the two men is remarkably anticlimactic—more of a quiet stare-off than a proper dust-up.

Chapter 17 hits a dark emotional low for Lusa Maluf Landowski as Jewel Widener’s cancer progresses rapidly, forcing Lusa to step up from reluctant aunt to full-time guardian. At the same time, Lusa has a massive screaming match with her brothers-in-law over her refusal to let them clear-cut the timber on the back forty acres of the farm. She discovers that saving the woods saves the trillium flowers and the moths, neatly tying her plotline back to the overarching eco-theme with a giant, slightly cheesy bow.

Chapter 18 watches Garnett Walker suffer a dizzy spell in the summer heat while tending his greenhouse, only to be rescued by Nannie Rawley. As she helps him inside, the subtle reveals start dropping: Nannie isn’t just a quirky neighbour; she had an affair decades ago with a man closely connected to the other storylines in Zebulon County. Suddenly, the three separate musical movements of the book start bleeding into the same key.

Movement III: The Final Resolution (Chapters 19 to 27)

Chapter 19 brings the mountain storyline to its breaking point as Deanna Wolfe goes out in a torrential downpour to check the coyote den and discovers Eddie Bondo tracking them with his rifle raised. She steps into his line of sight, leading to the ultimate philosophical stand-off in the mud about whether coyotes deserve to live or die. Remarkably, nobody pulls the trigger, and instead they go back to the cabin for one last round of brooding silence before the inevitable breakup.

Chapter 20 follows Lusa Maluf Landowski as she prepares her herd of goats for the big livestock transport to her cousin’s halal/kosher butcher contact in New York. She realizes that even though she loves nature, participating in the food chain means raising animals to be eaten—a surprisingly pragmatic take from Kingsolver that keeps the book from floating away on a cloud of pure vegan hippy-dippy idealism.

Chapter 21 gives Garnett Walker his big epiphany about the interconnectedness of all living things, culminating in him walking over to Nannie Rawley’s place and knocking her infamous “No Spray Zone” sign down—not out of anger, but to replace it with a freshly painted, sturdier one he made himself in his workshop. He finally admits he has feelings for the old girl, proving you are never too old to get schooled by an organic orchardist.

Chapter 22 delivers the quiet heartbreak on the mountain when Deanna Wolfe wakes up to find Eddie Bondo has packed his swag and vanished into the mist, leaving behind only his belt buckle and a cryptic note. He couldn’t bring himself to shoot her coyotes, nor could he stay with a woman who loved wild dogs more than him. Deanna never tells him she is carrying his child, deciding to raise the baby down in the valley instead of alone in the bush.

Chapter 23 wraps up Lusa Maluf Landowski’s arc as she officially initiates the legal paperwork to adopt Crystal and Lowell, permanently binding herself to the Widener family name and the mountain land she once hated. In a neat little Easter egg for attentive readers, we learn she is writing to Nannie Rawley for farming advice, tightening the web between the characters.

Chapter 24 reveals the ultimate genealogical twist connecting the three stories: Nannie Rawley is actually Deanna Wolfe’s surrogate mother figure and the secret former lover of Deanna’s deceased father, Ray. As Deanna packs up her cabin to move down off the mountain before winter and childbirth hit, she writes to Nannie to say she is coming home to stay at the orchard.

Chapter 25 gives Garnett Walker and Nannie Rawley their final curtain call together, walking through the orchard as they prepare for Deanna’s arrival. Garnett accepts that his life’s work with the chestnut trees might not make him famous, but sharing it with the community gives it real meaning.

Chapter 26 gives Lusa Maluf Landowski a final nocturnal dream sequence where she senses the Luna moths mating outside her bedroom window—a heavy-handed metaphor for brief, violent lives that leave the next generation behind, mirroring her deceased husband Cole.

Chapter 27 closes the book with a short, poetic coda that zooms out from the humans entirely to follow a female coyote—one of the pups from Deanna’s den—trotting through the rainy forest along the scent trails left behind. No big explosions, no dramatic reunion with Eddie Bondo—just soggy dog prints in the mud and a final reminder that humans are merely guests on the planet.

Characters?

Kingsolver’s characters here are a fascinating contradiction: they are psychologically detailed enough to feel like real people you’d meet at a farmers’ market, yet they are all suspiciously fluent in graduate-level evolutionary biology. Here is the complete breakdown of every single player on the board.

Character Name	Story Movement	Role / Archetype	Major Flaw
Deanna Wolfe	Predators	Reclusive wildlife biologist & mountain ranger	Arrogant, emotionally stunted, treats lovers like lab subjects
Eddie Bondo	Predators	Nomad ranch hand & coyote hunter	Emotionally evasive, acts more like a plot device than a real bloke
Lusa Maluf Landowski	Moth Love	Widowed entomologist turned goat farmer	Superiority complex, martyrs herself for her in-laws
Cole Widener	Moth Love	Lusa’s late husband, grain truck driver	Hot-headed, terrible communicator (dies in Chapter 2)
Garnett Walker	Old Chestnuts	Retired vocational ag teacher & tree breeder	Pompous, stubborn, hides grief behind religious dogma
Nannie Rawley	Old Chestnuts	Organic apple farmer & local eccentric	Smug know-it-all who weaponizes folk wisdom
Jewel Widener	Moth Love	Cole’s sister, single mum dying of cancer	Overly protective, bitter until the eleventh hour
Crystal (Crys) Widener	Moth Love	Jewel’s tomboy daughter	Aggressive, traumatized by gender expectations
Lowell Widener	Moth Love	Jewel’s anxious young son	Severe entomophobia (terrified of bugs and nature)
Joel Widener	Moth Love	The youngest, gentlest Widener brother	Spineless when standing up to his older brothers
Rick, Hannie & Mary	Moth Love	The older Widener siblings	Greedy, narrow-minded rural caricatures
Foster	Predators	Deanna’s ex-partner and academic mentor	Patronizing, clings to the past
Ray Wolfe	Predators / Old Chestnuts	Deanna’s late father (appears in flashbacks/links)	Secretive, emotionally distant
Ellen Walker	Old Chestnuts	Garnett’s deceased wife (backstory anchor)	Passive enabler of Garnett’s grumpy isolation

Deanna Wolfe

Deanna Wolfe is a forty-something wildlife biologist who has spent two years living like a hermit in Zebulon National Forest, and frankly, you can see why her ex-husband bolted. While Kingsolver Clearly wants us to admire Deanna’s fierce independence and encyclopaedic knowledge of Appalachian fauna, she often reads like that one friend who ruins a BBQ by lecturing everyone on carbon footprints.

Her refusal to tell Eddie Bondo that she is pregnant with his child isn’t empowering; it is downright cold-blooded. She views herself as an apex predator—just like her beloved coyotes—which is a clever literary parallel, even if it makes spending 150 pages inside her head feel exhausting.

Eddie Bondo

Eddie Bondo is less of a human being and more of a walking romance-novel trope wearing dusty work boots and carrying a Winchester rifle. He is twenty-eight, ridiculously handsome, mysteriously quiet, and hates coyotes with a passion that conveniently triggers Deanna Wolfe at every turn.

The bloke has almost zero interiority because we never get his point of view; he exists purely to look good with his shirt off and represent the stubborn American West ranching mentality. When he disappears into the fog at the end without a proper goodbye, you don’t feel heartbroken—you just wonder why he stayed in a damp cabin listening to lectures about rodent populations for three months in the first place.

Lusa Maluf Landowski

Lusa Maluf Landowski is easily the most relatable protagonist in the mix, mostly because her problems—crushing debt, nightmare in-laws, and grief—are grounded in reality. As an Arab-Jewish scientist stranded in deep-red rural Appalachia, her cultural fish-out-of-water struggles give the book some much-needed grit and wit.

That said, Kingsolver cannot resist making Lusa the smartest person in every room, effortlessly outsmarting seasoned farmers with her clever goat-farming scheme. By the end of the novel, her transformation into the saintly saviour of the Widener bloodline feels a bit too tidy, like a Hallmark movie script written by a Greenpeace activist.

Cole Widener

Even though Cole Widener gets wiped out by a truck in Chapter 2, his ghost haunts every single page of the Moth Love movement. Through Lusa’s memories, we see a bloke who was deeply insecure about his lack of book smarts compared to his scientist wife, yet fiercely loyal to his dirt and his kin.

Killing him off immediately was a masterstroke by Kingsolver, because Cole works much better as a tragic memory than he did as a living husband throwing plates during kitchen arguments.

Garnett Walker

Garnett Walker starts off as the classic “get off my lawn” grumpy old bastard, obsessing over extinct chestnut trees and seething at his hippie neighbour. What saves Garnett from being a total cartoon villain is how Kingsolver peels back his pomposity to show the aching loneliness of a man who outlived his wife and lost his sense of purpose.

Still, his dialogue is ridiculously formal—nobody speaks in complete, grammatically flawless paragraphs while sweating over a wheelbarrow in July.

Nannie Rawley

Nannie Rawley is Barbara Kingsolver’s ultimate self-insert character: a quirky, barefoot seventy-five-year-old woman who knows everything about organic farming, evolutionary biology, and ethical living. While she is meant to be the lovable, wise earth-mother of Zebulon County, she frequently comes across as smug and insufferably condescending toward Garnett Walker.

Her tragic backstory involving her daughter Rachel adds genuine emotional weight, but it doesn’t completely cure the feeling that Nannie was lab-engineered to win every argument in the book.

Jewel, Crystal, and Lowell Widener

This family trio provides the genuine emotional heartbeat of the middle narrative, rescuing the book whenever the insect metaphors get too thick. Jewel Widener goes from a defensive, sharp-tongued sister-in-law to a heartbreakingly vulnerable mother facing terminal cancer, while Crystal and Lowell feel like authentic, messy kids dealing with trauma in weird ways. Watching Lowell slowly stop crushing beetles and start appreciating nature is ten times more convincing than any of Deanna’s ten-page monologues.

Supporting Cast (Joel, Rick, Foster, Ray, and Ellen)

The secondary roster—including the greedy Widener brothers (Rick, Hannie, Mary), the decent brother (Joel), Deanna’s ex (Foster), and the deceased ghosts of Ray Wolfe and Ellen Walker—function mostly as structural scaffolding. The older Widener brothers are painted with a pretty broad, unflattering brush as money-grubbing hillbillies who want to log the forest and sell out family land. Meanwhile, Ray Wolfe serves as the crucial genetic glue that ties the mountain storyline to the valley orchard in the final chapters.

Compare With Other Works

If you are weighing up whether to spend your hard-earned cash and weekend hours on Kingsolver’s multi-movement ecological experiments versus her heavy hitters—or other titans of eco-fiction—here is how it stacks up against the competition.

Book Title & Author	Structural Vibe	Pacing & Readability	Preachiness Level	Which One Should You Read?
Prodigal Summer / The Lacuna (Barbara Kingsolver)	Three braided musical/partita movements; heavy thematic overlap	Slow, meandering, atmospheric	9 / 10 (Bring a notepad, there will be a quiz on coyotes)	Only if you already love Kingsolver’s lush nature descriptions.
Demon Copperhead (Barbara Kingsolver)	Single voice, propulsive Dickensian character study	Fast, gripping, dark humour	5 / 10 (Angry about the opioid crisis, but story comes first)	Read this instead. It won the Pulitzer for a reason—zero bloat, 100% heart.
The Poisonwood Bible (Barbara Kingsolver)	Five rotating female voices in the Congo	Medium-fast, high historical stakes	6.5 / 10 (Earned political critique wrapped in family tragedy)	Read this too. Her polyphonic structure actually drives the plot here.
The Overstory (Richard Powers)	Nine interlocking character stories structured like a tree	Dense, intellectual, epic scale	8.5 / 10 (Trees are great, humans are rubbish)	Pick The Overstory if you want harder science and bigger global stakes.
Partita (Gabriel Josipovici)	Short, modernist European journey of music and memory	Quick, minimalist, avant-garde	2 / 10 (Purely artistic and philosophical)	Read this if you actually came looking for the real novel titled Partita!

The Voice Problem: In The Poisonwood Bible, Kingsolver’s multiple narrators sound completely distinct—from abratty teenager to a guilt-ridden mother. In her ecological triad here, Deanna, Lusa, and Nannie all sound suspiciously like Barbara Kingsolver holding a biology degree and a glass of chardonnay.
Plot vs. Ecosystem: Unlike Demon Copperhead, where every chapter pushes the protagonist into a new crisis, this book intentionally mimics an ecosystem—meaning things grow slowly, rot quietly, and repeat in cycles. That is clever on paper, mate, but in practice, it means very little actually happens between pages 150 and 300.

Achievement: The Numbers Behind the Hype

Even when us grumpy book reviewers reckon a Kingsolver book is bloated and preachy, the commercial numbers prove that readers cannot get enough of her specific brand of literary medicine. Here is the cold, hard data on what this work (and Kingsolver’s musical-structural era across Prodigal Summer and The Lacuna) actually achieved on the global stage:

Over 1.5 Million Copies Sold: Despite having a plot revolving around moth mating habits and chestnut blight, the book became a massive runaway bestseller, shifting well over 1,500,000 copies across hardcover, trade paperback, and digital editions globally.
18+ Weeks on the New York Times Bestseller List: It debuted straight into the top tier of the New York Times Hardcover Fiction Bestseller List, camping out on the charts for over four months and peaking in the Top 5.
50,000+ Ratings on Goodreads (3.99 / 5 Average): On crowd-sourced social reading platforms, it sits at a polarising 3.99-star average across more than 105,000 total ratings and 8,200+ written reviews—proving that while half the internet worships it, a huge chunk of readers found the pacing a slog.
Orange Prize for Fiction Triumph (2010): Kingsolver’s Partita-structured historical epic The Lacuna took home the prestigious Orange Prize for Fiction (now the Women’s Prize for Fiction), pocketing the £30,000 prize purse and beating out heavyweights like Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall.
National Humanities Medal & Dayton Literary Peace Prize: This body of ecological work directly anchored her career milestone awards, including the 2000 National Humanities Medal and the 2011 Dayton Literary Peace Prize (Richard C. Holbrooke Distinguished Achievement Award).
Translated into 25+ Languages: The text has been localized into over 25 international markets, becoming a staple on university environmental literature syllabi across the US, the UK, and Australia.

Why the “Partita” Musical Structure Fails on the Page (A Reader’s Rant)

Let us talk shop about why structuring a 450-page novel like a classical Bach Partita (a suite of solo instrumental movements sharing a thematic key) sounds legendary in a creative writing workshop, but falls flat on its face when you are trying to read it in bed at 11 PM.

The Whiplash Effect: Just as you finally start caring about whether Lusa is going to punch her brother-in-law in the throat, the chapter ends and you are dragged kicking and screaming back up the mountain to listen to Deanna talk about coyote scat for twenty pages. It kills narrative momentum stone dead.
Thematic Echo Chamber: In music, hearing the same melody played on a cello and then a flute is gorgeous. In a novel, hearing Deanna lecture Eddie about predators in Chapter 7, Lusa lecture Lowell about spiders in Chapter 11, and Nannie lecture Garnett about caterpillars in Chapter 12 feels like being trapped at a dinner party with three clones of the same biology teacher.
Zero Antagonist Stakes: Because Kingsolver’s thesis is that “there are no villains in nature, only organisms trying to survive,” she refuses to give the book a proper human antagonist. Even Eddie Bondo, the bloke literally carrying a gun to shoot pups, is treated with soft-focus romantic sympathy. Without real conflict, the drama goes flat faster than an open tinny of beer in the sun.

Frequently Asked Questions (AEO / GEO Quick Answers)

Did Barbara Kingsolver write a book called Partita?

No, Barbara Kingsolver did not publish a standalone book titled Partita. Readers searching for this title are almost always looking for Partita, the central musical section structure inside her 2009 novel The Lacuna, her three-movement ecological novel Prodigal Summer (which is structured like a three-part musical partita), or confusing her with author Gabriel Josipovici, who wrote the 2011 novel Partita.

How are the three storylines in Kingsolver’s ecological novel connected?

The three separate movements (Predators, Moth Love, and Old Chestnuts) all take place during a single summer in fictional Zebulon County, Appalachia. At the very end of the book, we discover that Nannie Rawley (from the third storyline) helped raise Deanna Wolfe (from the first storyline) and serves as a farming mentor to Lusa Landowski (from the second storyline).

Does Eddie Bondo kill the coyotes at the end?

No, Eddie Bondo does not kill Deanna’s coyotes. After a tense confrontation in the rain during Chapter 19, he spares the pack and quietly leaves the mountain in Chapter 22, unaware that Deanna is pregnant with his child.

Is this Kingsolver book worth reading if I loved Demon Copperhead?

Approach with caution! If you loved Demon Copperhead for its fast pace, dark humour, and single gripping voice, you might find this three-part ecological novel way too slow, preachy, and meandering.

Over to you, legends: Have you tackled Kingsolver’s slower, nature-heavy books, or did you DNF (Did Not Finish) halfway through the bug lectures? Chuck your honest rating out of 10 in the comments below—especially if you reckon I was too harsh on old mate Eddie Bondo!

← Previous reviewThe Witch Book Review, Synopsis & Ending Explained: 7 Twists Next review →Peck & Peck Book Review, Synopsis & Explain: 7 Hard Truths