This Wretched Alchemy Review, Synopsis & Explain: 9 Brutal Cuts
If you reckon you have seen every deadly trial trope under the sun, buckle up, because Tina Mars just chucked a live grenade into the romantasy arena. Picture being forced into a gladiator-style bloodbath called the Call by the exact aristocratic dirtbags who butchered your older brother and locked your mother and little sister in a rotting dungeon. Your only ticket out of the dirt is to hunt down a mythic god-shard and slit the throat of the Warbringer, the realm’s most lethal alchemist. The problem? The monster you were hired to gut turns out to be a brooding, traumatised weapon who looks at you like you are the only soul worth saving in a decaying empire.
With a sentient snake tattoo coiled around her ribs and forbidden aeos magic thrumming in her veins, Revel Wyn has to play a rigged game where catching feelings is an instant death sentence. Let us be deadset honest before we dive into the deep end: while the premise sounds like pure gold on paper, the actual book reads like two unedited drafts stitched together after a sleepless weekend. We are talking top-shelf alchemy concepts clashing head-on with clunky info-dumps, modern slang that ruins the historical vibe, and an “enemies-to-lovers” romance that folds like a cheap deckchair in less than four days.
Have you already braved the Call, or are you trying to work out if this hyped-up debut deserves your hard-earned cash? Drop your unfiltered thoughts in the comments down below before we rip into the full chapter-by-chapter spoilers!
| Metric / Feature | The Brutal Breakdown | Critic’s Verdict |
| Book Title & Series | This Wretched Alchemy (Ruinous Fate Saga, #1) | Killer hook, screams dark adult romantasy |
| Author | Tina Mars | Great eye for magic concepts, desperately needed a ruthless developmental editor |
| Page Count & Structure | 400 Pages (38 Chapters + Epilogue across 4 Acts) | Choppy pacing that drags in Act 1 and sprints recklessly in Act 4 |
| Core Magic System | Alchemy, Blood Transmutation, Aeos, & God-Shards | 8.5/10 Concept, 4/10 Explanation – Cool Fullmetal Alchemist vibes, zero clear rules |
| The Romance Trope | Marketed as “Worse-Than-Enemies to Lovers” | 3/10 – Total stitch-up; it is insta-lust disguised as animosity over four days |
| Critique-to-Praise Ratio | 70% Critique / 30% Praise | High potential ruined by juvenile dialogue, purple prose, and continuity errors |

Outline
show
Detailed Summary
Part I: The Blood Debt and the Gilded Cage
Chapter 1 drops us straight into the suffocating grime of Revel Wyn’s life after the catastrophic fall of House Erevos at the hands of House Bellatoris. We watch Revel take a brutal beating in an underground transmutation pit, fighting purely to keep her imprisoned mother and little sister Clo fed in the dungeons below. Right out of the gate, the prose tries so hard to be flowery and poetic that it trips over its own metaphors, leaving you squinting twice just to work out who is punching whom. By the time the dust settles, Revel’s sentient snake tattoo is hissing warnings against her ribs, and we learn how her older brother was butchered while hunting down a divine god-shard.
Chapter 2 drags a bruised and bleeding Revel out of the cells and into the opulent, blood-stained halls of her Bellatoris captors. This is where the lore dump hits you with the subtlety of a brick to the face: major Houses, minor Houses, the tyrannical Prime who rules the fractured realm, and the ancient power of aeos transmutation. Revel’s inner monologue cycles relentlessly through childhood guilt over a fatal mistake she made years ago, establishing her as a wildly contradictory narrator. Just when she expects an executioner’s blade for trying to avenge her brother, the head of House Bellatoris offers her a poisoned chalice of a bargain.
Chapter 3 lays out the lethal terms of the Call, a bloody contest where the scions and heirs of the noble Houses butcher each other for the throne and a newly surfaced god-shard. Because House Bellatoris wants their hands clean, they force Revel to enter the crucible as their proxy champion. Adding insult to injury, they slap an extra condition onto her contract: she does not just have to survive the arena, she has to assassinate Axus Tassian, the Prime’s undefeated enforcer known across the realm as the Warbringer. If she pulls it off, her mother and sister walk free; if she stuffs it up, her entire bloodline gets wiped off the map.
Chapter 4 focuses on Revel’s grim preparation before being shipped off to the imperial capital, introducing us to the gritty mechanics of alchemical transmutation. Unlike your standard wand-waving fantasy, every spell here demands a physical toll, corrupting the user’s body and sanity if they push the boundaries of natural law too far. Revel shares a brief, emotional visitation with her sister Clo, reminding the reader why she is willing to play assassin for the people she loathes most. Even so, the dialogue between the guards and the prisoners sounds weirdly modern—like fifteen-year-olds trading TikTok one-liners rather than hardened survivors in a dark fantasy realm.
Chapter 5 transports the tributes to the Prime’s seat of power, a decadent metropolis blending Roman gladiator architecture with eerie Asian folklore aesthetics. During the grand convocation of the Houses, Revel sizes up the other arrogant scions vying for the god-shard, including the sharp-tongued Dex and the deceptively lethal Mauve. Then, the doors blow open and Axus Tassian makes his entrance, radiating enough dark, lethal aeos energy to make the whole room freeze. Instead of acting like the ruthless butcher promised on the blurb, the Warbringer locks eyes with Revel from across the hall, and any real threat between them evaporates into instant, cheesy tension.
Chapter 6 follows the chaotic banquet after the opening ceremony, where political daggers are drawn over goblets of spiced wine. Revel tries to do some proper reconnaissance on her target, expecting Axus to be a sadistic brute she can easily despise before slipping a blade between his ribs. Instead, he corners her on a shadowed balcony, and their supposed “banter” reads like a stilted one-liner contest where two drafts with completely different relationship dynamics were accidentally glued together. For a bloke marketed as her worse-than-enemy, he is weirdly gentle from minute one, making the whole assassination setup feel toothless.
Chapter 7 dives into the preliminary assessment trials inside the imperial colosseum, where each House heir has to demonstrate their mastery over alchemy and aeos before the Prime. Revel holds back her true Erevos bloodline capabilities, relying on street-fighting grit and her sentient snake tattoo to scrape through a gauntlet of alchemically mutated beasts. The action should be gripping, yet the choppy world-building leaves you scratching your head over how the magic limits actually work. Watching from the high dais, the Prime takes a sinister interest in her unorthodox style, while Axus steps in to block a cheap shot from a rival scion aimed at Revel’s back.
Chapter 8 wraps up the opening act on the eve of the main expedition, locking the competitors into the inner sanctum before the shard hunt officially begins. Unable to sleep, Revel wanders into the restricted alchemy archives and stumbles straight into Axus, who is nursing old scars caused by the Prime’s cruel conditioning. They trade dialogue over ancient transmutation texts, discovering that Revel is a poet at heart who shares his obsession with a pair of tragic historical writers. While the poetic parallels are meant to be swoon-worthy, Revel’s abrupt flip-flopping from “cold-blooded killer” to “starstruck teenager” gives you severe narrative whiplash.
Part II: Into the Crucible of the Call
Chapter 9 sounds the war horns as the gates of the capital swing open, launching the heirs into the cursed outer territories to hunt down the god-shard. The terrain is an atmospheric nightmare fuelled by unstable aeos rifts and folklore monstrosities that feast on alchemical energy. Revel immediately breaks away from the main Bellatoris pack, intending to set an ambush for Axus in the mist-choked ravines. Naturally, her half-baked plan goes pear-shaped within twenty minutes when a pack of flesh-warped beasts corners her against a cliffside, proving she has zero tactical discipline.
Chapter 10 delivers a chaotic action sequence where Revel and Axus are forced to fight back-to-back against the mutated horde. Mars shows flashes of brilliance in the imagery here; the visual of Axus transmuting stone and iron using blood-etched arrays is undeniably cool. However, weak copy-editing rears its ugly head midway through the scrap, with continuity errors in character positioning that force you to backtrack a page just to check if you skipped a paragraph. Once the monsters are dead, Revel goes right back to whining in her head about how hot and dangerous her target is.
Chapter 11 forces a temporary truce between Revel, Axus, Dex, and Mauve as an alchemical storm rolls across the wasteland, trapping them inside an abandoned shrine. Around the campfire, Dex and Mauve easily steal the show, providing the only reason many critical readers didn’t DNF the book early. Dex brings genuine charisma, while Mauve keeps everyone on their toes with her sharp, self-serving pragmatism. Meanwhile, if you actually count the timeline, Revel and Axus have only known each other for about forty-eight hours, yet they are already staring at each other like tortured soulmates.
Chapter 12 peels back the layers of Axus’s grim backstory during a quiet night watch while the others sleep. We learn that the Prime tore him away from his family as a young boy, breaking his mind and body on the anvil of war to forge the ultimate living weapon. Axus admits he knows Revel is hiding a lethal agenda, though he hasn’t quite clocked that he is the name at the top of her hit list. Rather than using his vulnerability to strike and save her family, Revel lets him tend to her alchemical burns, acting more like a lovesick schoolgirl than a desperate prisoner.
Chapter 13 ramps up the treachery when dawn breaks and a rival faction of House heirs launches a vicious ambush on the shrine. Blood and transmuted fire fly everywhere, forcing Revel to tap deeper into her forbidden Erevos aeos than she ever intended in public. Her sentient snake tattoo lunges off her skin to intercept a lethal curse, leaving the survivors gawking at a piece of magic that the author still forgets to properly explain. In the chaos, the group gets fractured, sending Revel and Axus tumbling down a subterranean chasm into the forgotten ruins beneath the realm.
Chapter 14 slows the pacing to a crawl as the duo navigates the bioluminescent tunnels of an ancient pre-Prime civilisation. The prose here gets so overly lyrical and drowned in purple metaphor that reading feels like wading through wet cement. Still, the claustrophobic atmosphere forces Revel to confront her deep-seated trauma from the night House Erevos burned. Axus talks her down from a panic attack, delivering a soft, comforting speech that makes zero sense coming from a bloke feared across the continent as the Warbringer.
Chapter 15 brings us to the underground library scene where the historical lore is supposed to click into place. Surrounded by rotting scrolls and statues of forgotten deities, Revel and Axus uncover banned manuscripts written by the two ancient poets they both idolise. Instead of giving us a coherent history of how the Houses and the Prime came to power, the book dumps fragmented riddles that leave the land’s background muddled and confusing. The banter shifts from forced snark to heavy yearning, even though any logical reader is screaming that it has only been three bloody days since they met.
Chapter 16 shatters the romantic bubble when the pair deciphers a stone tablet revealing that god-shards are not benevolent gifts from the heavens at all. Instead, they are calcified fragments of slaughtered deities that slowly devour the humanity of whoever binds them, explaining the rot at the heart of the Prime’s regime. Before they can process the revelation, an ancient guardian construct powered by corrupted aeos wakes up to defend the archive. The ensuing scrap pushes both of them to exhaustion, leaving Axus gravely wounded after he shields Revel from a collapsing pillar.
Chapter 17 sees Revel dragging a half-conscious Warbringer into a hidden alcove, dagger in hand and nobody around to stop her from finishing her contract. This is the moment where the book should have delivered peak moral agony, pitting her family’s survival directly against her growing feelings. Revel presses the steel to his jugular, thinking of her mother and sister rotting in House Bellatoris’s cells, only for Axus to open his eyes and tell her to do it if it buys her peace. Unable to butcher a bloke offering his own neck on a platter, she chucks the knife aside and uses her own life force to heal his shattered ribs.
Chapter 18 follows the awkward, contradictory aftermath of Revel’s failed assassination attempt as they finally claw their way back to the surface. Hold on—if she refuses to kill him when he is unconscious and bleeding out, how on earth is the plot supposed to maintain assassination tension for the remaining two hundred pages? They reunite with Dex and Mauve on the edge of the Blighted Marches, only to find out that House Bellatoris has sent a secondary squad of enforcers into the field to ensure Revel doesn’t get cold feet.
Part III: The Rot Beneath the Throne
Chapter 19 kicks off the second half of the novel with a confrontation in the petrified forest, where House Bellatoris’s goons corner Revel while she is separated from the group. They remind her that her sister Clo will pay in blood if Axus Tassian is still breathing by the end of the trial. Pushed into a corner, Revel unleashes a feral display of Erevos blood-alchemy, slaughtering the messengers to buy herself time. Rather than owning her massive lie to Axus, her immature inner monologue starts projecting blame onto him for keeping secrets about the Prime, which makes her downright insufferable to read.
Chapter 20 drops an abrupt spice scene into the middle of the wilderness when Axus tracks the scent of blood back to Revel in the pouring rain. Seeing her covered in gore and shaking with rage, he pulls her in, and four days of forced insta-lust boils over against the bark of a dead tree. Many critical readers pointed out that this whole section reads like a YA novel with adult spice scenes tacked on to bump up the age rating. Given that her mother and sister are literally starving in a cage while she hooks up with her target, Revel’s priorities feel wildly out of whack.
Chapter 21 drags the narrative back to the overarching plot as the survivors reach the outer perimeter of the Sunken Citadel, where the god-shard rests. Here, the pacing goes completely haywire—simultaneously dragging its feet with repetitive inner angst while glossing over how the citadel’s alchemical wards actually operate. Revel and Axus agree to form a secret alliance to claim the shard for themselves and use its power to overthrow both House Bellatoris and the Prime. Of course, Revel conveniently leaves out the tiny detail that she was originally hired by Bellatoris to put him in a pine box.
Chapter 22 puts the squad through a psychological trial guarding the citadel’s outer bridge, crafted to weaponise a trespasser’s worst memories. We finally see the full flashback of the night Revel’s brother was murdered and the childhood mistake that allowed House Bellatoris to breach Erevos’s wards. While the emotional trauma is meant to be devastating, the choppy editing makes the transition between flashback and present action jarring to follow. Meanwhile, Axus relives his own horrific conditioning at the hands of the Prime, cementing their bond as two broken pawns on a rigged board.
Chapter 23 shifts the spotlight onto Dex and Mauve as they breach the inner courtyards during a deadly puzzle-trap sequence. A betrayal within the wider pool of House scions triggers a bloodbath that wipes out half the remaining competitors in a single afternoon. Amidst the carnage, Mauve makes a ruthlessly pragmatic move that saves Dex’s life at the expense of a minor House alliance, proving she is a far more compelling morally grey character than the actual heroine. It is easily one of the strongest chapters in the middle stretch because it gives us a break from Revel’s whining.
Chapter 24 brings a brief calm before the storm as the core group camps inside an ancient alchemical conservatory before the final push for the shard. Revel and Axus share a quiet night together behind warded doors, discussing what a life free from warring Houses and blood oaths might look like. They reflect on the poetic parallel that they were raised as weapons rather than human beings. Even here, the dialogue swings wildly between overly ornate poetry and jarring modern slang that pulls you straight out of the fantasy setting.
Chapter 25 detonates the third-act betrayal bomb when morning arrives and the final chamber housing the god-shard is unsealed. A rival scion from House Bellatoris—who survived the earlier purge—confronts them at the threshold and spills the beans right in front of Axus. With a sadistic grin, the heir reveals the blood bargain Revel signed in Chapter 3, exposing that every step she took alongside the Warbringer was funded by an assassination contract on his head. Watching the betrayal crash over Axus’s face is one of the few emotional beats in the romance that actually lands with proper weight.
Chapter 26 captures the fallout of the reveal as the chamber erupts into a three-way alchemical free-for-all for the suspended god-shard. Frankly, half the audience at this point was rooting for Axus to actually turn on Revel and put us out of our misery. Instead, while Revel battles the Bellatoris heir in a desperate bid to prove her loyalty, Axus shuts down behind a wall of cold silence. Just as Revel lands a killing blow on her blackmailer, the Prime’s elite imperial guard breaches the ceiling, revealing the entire Call was a rigged trap from page one.
Chapter 27 sees the Prime’s forces seizing control of the chamber while Axus is forced back into his role as the regime’s obedient hound to stop them from executing Revel on the spot. In a display of cold detachment, Axus claps alchemical suppression cuffs onto Revel’s wrists himself, whispering a cryptic warning that feels like both a promise and a goodbye. The god-shard is claimed by the crown, Dex is dragged off in chains alongside the other surviving heirs, and Revel’s plan to free her family goes up in smoke.
Part IV: The Wretched Reckoning
Chapter 28 hauls the chained survivors back to the imperial capital in iron wagons, stripping away all the illusions of the wilderness. Revel sits in the dark, her aeos muted by suppression iron and her sentient snake tattoo dormant against her bruised skin. She beats herself up endlessly for failing both her family and Axus, cycling right back into the repetitive, self-pitying inner monologue that bogged down Act 1. Still, the grim, shadow-soaked dread thickening the air as they approach the capital’s execution squares keeps the pages turning.
Chapter 29 throws Revel into the Prime’s high dungeon, where she receives a chilling visit from the tyrannical ruler himself. Here, the author dumps a massive pile of late-game lore about the true origin of House Erevos and why her brother was really murdered while chasing a god-shard. It turns out her brother had uncovered a way to shatter the Prime’s divine immortality using Erevos bloodline alchemy. The Prime informs Revel that her mother and sister have been transferred from House Bellatoris’s cells directly to the imperial palace as leverage for the grand finale.
Chapter 30 is the colosseum showstopper that finally injects real adrenaline into the final act. Dragged into the packed grand arena for a public “reckoning” disguised as the Call’s closing ceremony, Revel is pitted directly against Axus in a fight to the death before the entire realm. With Clo and her mother suspended in an alchemical cage above a pit of acid, Revel has zero room to pull her punches, and neither does Axus under the Prime’s mind-warping aeos compulsion. The duel that follows is visceral and heavy, finally delivering on the dark gladiator promise of the premise.
Chapter 31 pushes the colosseum bloodbath to its breaking point as Revel realises Axus is subtly manipulating his transmutation arrays during their strikes. He isn’t trying to kill her; he is using the violent collisions of their magic to overload the suppression collar around her neck and feed her tactical cues in ancient poet ciphers. Catching onto his gambit, Revel channels the full weight of her forbidden Erevos aeos, causing her snake tattoo to manifest into a massive shadowy chimera in the arena dust. The crowd goes ballistic as the scripted execution spirals into a magical mutiny.
Chapter 32 sees Dex and Mauve breaking free from the tribute holding pens with the help of an underground rebel cell, turning the colosseum floor into a chaotic warzone. While Dex scrambles toward the winch mechanisms to save Revel’s family from the acid pit, Mauve settles an old score with the remaining House Bellatoris elders in the VIP box. The pacing here sprints at breakneck speed, though several tactical twists feel pulled out of thin air because the earlier world-building was too choppy to set them up properly.
Chapter 33 brings Revel and Axus face-to-face with the Prime on the high imperial dais while the colosseum burns around them. Attempting to bind the newly recovered god-shard mid-battle, the Prime unleashes a wave of divine transmutation that nearly liquefies everyone within fifty metres. Revel and Axus combine their opposing alchemical affinities—her volatile shadow aeos merging with his iron-and-blood transmutation—to crack the Prime’s defensive barrier. Just as the tyrant staggers back, the first of three chaotic finale plot twists slams into the story.
Chapter 34 drops the bombshell that Revel’s late brother didn’t act alone when he hunted the original god-shard; he was working alongside an inside informant within the Prime’s inner circle. That informant turns out to be none other than Axus himself, meaning the Warbringer knew who Revel was long before she ever set foot in the Call. Wait a second—while that explains why he was so weirdly soft on her from Chapter 5, it also creates massive plot holes regarding why he let House Bellatoris torture her in the pits for months!
Chapter 35 escalates the chaos as the cracked god-shard destabilises, threatening to level the entire capital city in an alchemical explosion. Forced to choose between finishing off the retreating Prime or saving thousands of innocent lives in the lower districts, Revel steps into the breach. Drawing the raw, corrupted divine energy into her own body and her sentient tattoo, she performs a forbidden transmutation that should turn her into ash. Axus anchors her to the physical plane by forging an unbreakable blood-soul tether between their aeos cores, saving her life at a steep cost to their freedom.
Chapter 36 deals with the smoking aftermath of the colosseum’s collapse as rebel forces and loyalist legions clash in the streets. Dex manages to haul Clo and Revel’s mother out of the wreckage alive, though her mother is gravely poisoned by lingering alchemical fallout. When a dazed Revel wakes up amidst the rubble, she realises the horrific price of the god-shard absorption and the soul-tether: her magic is now permanently knotted to Axus’s life force, and dark divine corruption is creeping up her veins.
Chapter 37 chucks a second kitchen-sink twist at the reader when Revel confronts her rescued mother in the rebel safehouse. Through feverish confessions, her mother reveals that Revel is not actually a biological daughter of House Erevos at all, and her sentient snake tattoo is an ancient seal placed on her infancy to hide her direct royal lineage to the fallen gods. Dropping a “secret divine princess” trope at the ninety-five percent mark on top of an already muddled magic system feels ridiculously overcrowded.
Chapter 38 brings the main narrative to a frantic climax as imperial reinforcements surround the safehouse district to reclaim the living vessel of the god-shard. To buy time for Dex, Mauve, Clo, and her mother to escape through the smuggling tunnels, Axus makes a sacrificial play. Using the newly forged soul-tether to freeze Revel in place against her will, he surrenders himself back to the Prime’s vanguard, painting himself as a double agent who neutralised the Erevos threat. Revel is dragged into exile screaming his name as the city gates slam shut.
Epilogue switches perspectives for a chilling final glimpse inside the Prime’s throne room weeks after the Call’s bloody conclusion. Axus is kneeling in chains before the tyrant, having subjected himself to a memory-wiping alchemical ritual so the Prime cannot torture Revel’s escape coordinates out of his mind. However, as the Prime turns his back, a faint shadow-scale flickers across Axus’s wrist—proving the god-shard bond between them is mutating into something darker for Book 2. It is a dramatic cliffhanger, even if getting there felt like surviving an editing warzone.
Characters?
Every character in this realm is carrying enough trauma to sink a battleship, though the writing makes you root for the side cast way harder than the actual heroine. Drop a comment below telling us whether you loved Revel or wanted to chuck her off a cliff!
| Character Name | House / Allegiance | Core Ability / Weapon | Moral Alignment | Execution Score |
| Revel Wyn | Fallen House Erevos (Forced proxy for Bellatoris) | Shadow Aeos, Blood Alchemy, Sentient Snake Tattoo, Poet | Chaotic Contradictory (Immature & indecisive) | 4.5/10 |
| Axus Tassian | The Prime’s Enforcer (The Warbringer) | High-tier Iron & Blood Transmutation, Secret Informant | Lawful Grey / Soft-Hearted Weapon | 7.0/10 |
| Dex | Rival House Scion / Rebel Ally | Kinetic Alchemy & Trap Disarmament | Chaotic Good (Scene Stealer) | 8.5/10 |
| Mauve | Rival House Heir | Poison & Illusion Transmutation | True Neutral (Cut-throat Pragmatist) | 8.5/10 |
| Clo Wyn | Fallen House Erevos | Latent Alchemical Sensitivity | Lawful Good (The Plot Device Hostage) | 6.0/10 |
| The Prime | Supreme Ruler of the Realm | Bound God-Shards & Compulsion Aeos | Lawful Evil Overlord | 5.5/10 |
Revel Wyn
- The Contradictory Poet-Assassin: Revel Wyn is pitched as a fierce, morally grey survivor who writes poetry in her head while slitting throats to save her imprisoned mother and sister. When she finally unleashes her blood alchemy in the colosseum finale, you can see the badass heroine Tina Mars wanted to write.
- Why She Drives Readers Mad: Revel Wyn comes across as borderline insufferable for huge chunks of the book. Her behaviour and dialogue read like a moody fourteen-year-old rather than an adult assassin, and her constant flip-flopping between self-righteous anger and instant lust for her target makes it nearly impossible to stay invested in her voice.
Axus Tassian
- The Disarming Warbringer: Axus Tassian carries the romance on his bruised shoulders, blending lethal alchemical power with quiet trauma and a soft spot for ancient poetry. He is the classic tortured book boyfriend who falls first and sacrifices his own mind in the epilogue to protect the woman he loves.
- Where the Character Stumbles: Because Axus Tassian is secretly working with the resistance from the jump, he never actually acts like an enemy toward Revel Wyn. His dialogue often gets dragged down into cheesy one-liners that strip away his intimidating “Warbringer” aura way too early.
Dex
- The Reason You Don’t DNF: Dex is one of the rival scions thrown into the Call who quickly becomes the best part of the entire book. Whenever the narrative starts choking on purple prose or Revel Wyn’s repetitive angst, Dex steps in with natural charisma and genuine loyalty that keeps the story afloat.
- Where the Character Stumbles: Because the editing is so choppy, Dex disappears for long stretches in the middle chapters when his perspective on the warring noble Houses could have fixed the messy world-building.
Mauve
- The True Morally Grey Icon: While the marketing tries to convince us the leads are dark and ruthless, Mauve is the one who actually delivers the goods. She enters the trials with her own hidden agenda, makes cold-blooded tactical plays without whining about it, and keeps the tension razor-sharp whenever she is on the page.
- Where the Character Stumbles: Her sudden pivot into a ride-or-die rebel accomplice during the final colosseum escape feels rushed due to the chaotic fourth-act pacing.
Clo Wyn
- The Emotional Leverage: As Revel Wyn’s younger sister locked away by House Bellatoris, Clo Wyn represents the human cost of the noble Houses’ greed. Her danger in the acid cage during Chapter 30 provides the high-stakes fuel for the climax.
- Where the Character Stumbles: She barely exists as a real person with her own personality, functioning purely as a hostage plot device to force Revel Wyn into the arena.
The Prime
- The God-Shard Tyrant: The Prime rules the fractured realm from his blood-soaked dais, hoarding divine god-shards and orchestrating the Call to keep the noble Houses weak and divided.
- Where the Character Stumbles: Because the historical background of the realm is explained so poorly, The Prime feels like a cardboard cutout fantasy dictator rather than a complex political villain.
Compare with other works
If you are trying to work out how This Wretched Alchemy stacks up against other heavy hitters in the fantasy and romantasy trenches, check out this side-by-side comparison:
| Comparable Title / Work | Shared DNA & Similarities | Where This Wretched Alchemy Wins | Where This Wretched Alchemy Loses Badly |
| Fullmetal Alchemist (Hiromu Arakawa) | Alchemical transmutation, blood tolls, corrupting philosopher’s stone / god-shard equivalents, state military enforcer (Axus). | Injects high-heat adult romance and dark gladiator colosseum trials into the alchemy subgenre. | Fails to explain the basic rules of its magic system, leaving readers confused until the final page. |
| The Serpent and the Wings of Night (Carissa Broadbent) | Deadly divine tournament (The Call vs. Kejari), stabby heroine with family trauma, alliance with a lethal male rival. | Integrates cool sentient tattoo visuals and folklore beast designs into the arena battles. | Broadbent writes a masterclass slow-burn; Mars rushes a forced romance in four days with cheesy YA banter. |
| Trial of the Sun Queen (Nisha J. Tuli) | Imprisoned heroine forced to compete as a proxy for a rival noble faction in a lethal royal contest. | Darker, moodier atmosphere with heavier emotional fallout in the final chapters. | Tuli’s editing and continuity are clean, whereas Mars suffers from jarring draft-stitching and info-dumps. |
| The Hunger Games / Gladiator Fantasy | Oppressed tributes thrown into a rigged imperial spectacle by a tyrannical ruler (The Prime). | Blends blood alchemy and divine shard lore into the arena survival formula. | Revel Wyn lacks Katniss’s discipline, spending half the trial acting immature and forgetting her mission. |
Achievement
Despite getting roasted by critical reviewers for its rough editing and polarising heroine, the commercial machinery and early numbers behind This Wretched Alchemy are seriously impressive:
| Achievement Category | Specific Metric / Milestone | Industry Context & Impact |
| Goodreads & StoryGraph Engagement | 3.67 Average Rating across 967+ early ratings and 822+ full written reviews ahead of its November 10, 2026 retail drop. | A massive 85% review-to-rating ratio, showing that whether readers give it 5 stars or 2 stars, nobody walks away indifferent. |
| Global Publishing Footprint | Published across 6 distinct editions (Hardcover, Deluxe Limited Edition, Kindle $16.99, Audiobook, UK & ANZ formats) under Macmillan / St. Martin’s Press (ISBN: 9781250456564). | Scored a major traditional publishing rollout with custom sprayed edges for a debut author who joined Goodreads in July 2019. |
| Bestseller Endorsement Sweep | Co-signed on the cover by 5 massive romantasy heavyweights: Carissa Broadbent, Thea Guanzon, Nisha J. Tuli, H.M. Wolfe, and Brooke Fast. | Secured blurbs from the biggest names in the trials-and-tournaments subgenre before book one even hit shelves. |
| Pre-Release Reader Momentum | Tracked over 194+ active simultaneous ARC readers in October 2026 with 949+ likes on Goodreads’ featured Romantasy Genre Report spotlight. | Cemented its spot as one of the most fiercely debated romantasy debuts of late 2026. |
5 Editorial Fails vs. 4 Redeeming Hits: The Brutal Breakdown
Because this book feels like a tug-of-war between a brilliant imagination and a asleep-at-the-wheel copy editor, here is the exact breakdown of why critical readers are giving it 2.5 stars while die-hard fans are screaming for Book 2:
The 5 Biggest Fails (Why Critics Are Roasting It)
- 1. The “Two Frankensteined Drafts” Problem: Multiple times throughout the book, the tone and relationship dynamic shift so abruptly between scenes that you have to flip back three pages to check if your Kindle glitched. It genuinely reads like two separate drafts were combined without smoothing the seams.
- 2. Info-Dumping With a Brick: Instead of weaving the history of the warring Houses and the Prime naturally into the action, the book chucks dense blocks of confusing lore at your head and still leaves you with unanswered questions by Chapter 38.
- 3. Juvenile YA Banter in an Adult Setting: For a dark adult fantasy about blood alchemy and family murder, the characters talk like modern teenagers competing in a cheesy one-liner contest. Slapping a spicy scene into Chapter 20 doesn’t magically make immature characters feel like adults.
- 4. Flowery Purple Prose Overload: While Mars tries to justify the overly ornate language by making Revel Wyn a poet, the excessive metaphors bog down the pacing and make simple room descriptions exhausting to decode.
- 5. Spelling, Grammar, and Continuity Slips: Even in late copies, readers clocked frustrating continuity errors and over-edited clunky phrasing that pulled them straight out of the immersion.
The 4 Redeeming Hits (Why It Still Hooks Readers)
- 1. A Top-Tier Alchemical Concept: Mixing Roman gladiator trials with Fullmetal Alchemist-style blood transmutation and divine god-shards is a killer concept that stands out from generic fae courts.
- 2. Shadow-Soaked, Moody Atmosphere: When the prose stops trying too hard and focuses on the rot, dread, and ambition of the arena, you can practically taste the ash in the air.
- 3. Side Characters Who Carry the Squad: Dex and Mauve bring genuine spark, wit, and unpredictable grey morality whenever Revel Wyn gets too annoying to stomach.
- 4. An Absolute Gut-Punch Ending: The final five chapters in the colosseum and the brutal soul-tether cliffhanger deliver the high-stakes betrayal the first half of the book only pretended to have.
What is your ultimate deal-breaker when reading a hyped romantasy: can you forgive messy editing and juvenile dialogue if the magic system and ending slap, or is bad pacing an instant DNF for you? Sound off in the comments below!