Book Review: Good Spirits Synopsis Explain – 7 Ways This Haunt Falls Flat
G’day, mates – imagine a ghostly Irish bloke popping up to “haunt” a chirpy antiques lass during the silly season, only for their so-called redemption arc to fizzle like a dud firecracker.
The drama peaks when Nolan, the Ghost of Christmas Past, realises his assignment Harriet ain’t the Scrooge he reckoned, leading to a bungled mix of time-travel mishaps and forced feels that leave you questioning if the afterlife’s got a returns policy.
It’s meant to be a cozy holiday romp, but crikey, it trips over its own ethereal feet with plot holes big enough to drive a ute through.
Detailed Summary
Righto, let’s dive into this ghostly yarn chapter by chapter, ’cause fair dinkum, it needs a proper dissection to show where it goes pear-shaped.
I’ll break it down section by section, keeping things clear as a bell, with each bit chunked into 4-5 sentences before a breather.
This’ll be a long yarn – reckon we’re pushing well over 2000 words here, as we unpack every twist, turn, and tumble.
No fluff, just the nitty-gritty on why this book’s more miss than hit.
Chapter 1: The Unexpected Visitor
Nolan Callahan, our grumpy ghost bloke from a century ago, gets his annual gig as the Ghost of Christmas Past.
He’s all set for a quick in-and-out haunt, like he’s done for yonks, floating in limbo waiting for the big upstairs.
But blimey, he lands in Harriet York’s cozy antiques shop, decked out like Santa’s workshop on steroids.
Harriet’s sipping dodgy peppermint tea, minding her own biz, when this rugged Irish sailor type materialises, claiming he’s there to audit her soul.
She’s a people-pleaser through and through, always bending over backwards for others, so she’s gobsmacked – why her?
The chapter sets up the confusion right off the bat, with Nolan barking orders and Harriet just blinking like a stunned mullet.
Their banter starts snappy, but it feels forced, like the author’s trying too hard to make ’em spark.
Nolan explains the rules: they’ve got till Christmas Eve to revisit her past and fix her “wrongs,” or he’s off to ghostie purgatory again.
Harriet’s not buying it at first, thinking it’s a prank or she’s lost the plot.
But when he zaps ’em to a memory of her childhood Christmas, she realises this ain’t no joke.
Chapter 2: The First Memory Dive
Off they go to Harriet’s past, landing in a snowy scene from her kiddie days.
She’s a curly-haired tyke, helping her Aunt Matilda in the antiques shop, all wide-eyed and innocent.
Nolan’s pushing her to spot some “mistake,” but all they see is her being a top-notch helper, no nasties in sight.
He’s scratching his ethereal noggin, ’cause this ain’t like his usual Scrooge assignments – no greed, no meanness, just pure sunshine.
Harriet starts questioning if maybe she’s too much of a pushover, always saying yes to everyone.
Back in the present, Nolan’s magic starts glitching – he can touch things, feel cold, which ain’t normal for a ghost.
Harriet offers him a cuppa, and he’s shocked he can taste it, leading to a awkward moment where they almost brush hands.
The chapter drags here, repeating how baffled they are without much progress.
Nolan grumbles about bureaucracy in the afterlife, with receptionists and bosses – it’s meant to be funny, but lands flat like a bad dad joke.
They decide to push on, but you can already see the plot’s wheels spinning without traction.
Chapter 3: Family Shadows Emerge
Flashback to a tense family dinner, where Harriet’s mum is a right piece of work, criticising her every move.
Harriet’s trying to keep the peace, as always, but it’s clear she’s bottling up resentment.
Nolan watches, expecting a big reveal, but it’s just everyday family drama – no explosive secrets.
He prods her to stand up for herself in the memory, but of course, it don’t change the past.
She’s left feeling raw, wondering if her people-pleasing stems from this toxic dynamic.
In the shop, they chat over biscuits, and Nolan shares a snippet of his own life – dying young at sea, all alone.
It’s a vulnerability moment, but it feels tacked on, like the book’s rushing the emotional bond.
Harriet’s cat, a fluffy black moggy, takes a shine to Nolan, which is cute but doesn’t add much depth.
The chapter ends with Nolan fading a bit, hinting his time’s limited, but the tension’s as weak as watered-down beer.
They plan the next dive, but you’re left yawning, waiting for something to actually happen.
Chapter 4: Sweet Tooth and Sparks
They zip to a uni memory, where Harriet’s baking treats for mates who take her for granted.
She’s all smiles, but inside, she’s lonely, forcing herself into spaces that don’t fit.
Nolan points out how she’s dimming her own light, but it’s preachy, not insightful.
Harriet defends herself, saying it’s just who she is, leading to their first proper blue.
Back home, the air’s thick with unspoken attraction – Nolan’s starting to feel human again, craving her touch.
He admits he’s never haunted someone so… nice, and they share a laugh over his ghostly mishaps.
But the spice ramps up too quick; one minute arguing, next he’s all broody and intense.
Harriet questions why he’s really here, suspecting the afterlife’s cocked up the assignment.
The chapter tries for humour with Nolan trying modern gadgets, but it’s clichéd as.
They agree to keep digging, but the pace is sluggish, like wading through treacle.
Chapter 5: Deeper into the Past
Off to a heartbreaking scene: Harriet’s aunt’s funeral, where she’s left the shop but feels utterly alone.
Family ignores her grief, and she swallows it down, ever the pleaser.
Nolan’s moved, seeing parallels to his own lonely death.
He comforts her in the memory, which ain’t supposed to happen, causing a magical glitch.
Harriet realises their threads are intertwined somehow, but it’s vague as fog.
Present-day, they bond over shared loss, with Nolan opening up about his sailor days.
The romance heats up – a near-kiss that’s all tension, no payoff yet.
But the dialogue’s cheesy, like a Hallmark flick on steroids.
Harriet researches ghosts online, finding nada useful.
Chapter closes with Nolan’s boss calling – time’s ticking, mate.
Chapter 6: Magical Mayhem Builds
Flash to Harriet’s first job, where a boss takes advantage of her kindness.
She quits in the memory? Nah, just relives the regret.
Nolan urges her to see her worth, but it’s repetitive from earlier bits.
His powers weaken more – he can eat, sleep, feel pain.
They’re both freaked, wondering if he’s becoming human or she’s going ghostly.
In the shop, they experiment with his abilities, leading to funny fails like phasing through walls wrong.
Attraction boils over into a steamy scene, but it feels rushed for the plot’s sake.
Harriet’s mum calls, stirring up old wounds.
Nolan encourages her to confront it, but she’s not ready.
The mystery deepens: why them specifically?
Chapter 7: Threads Unravel
Back to Nolan’s era – wait, a twist! They visit his past, not hers.
He’s on a ship, young and vital, before the storm that did him in.
Harriet sees his loneliness, mirroring her own.
It’s a revelation: their souls are linked through some antique item in her shop.
But the connection’s explained poorly, leaving you scratching your head.
Present tense, they pore over old logs, piecing it together.
Romance intensifies with confessions of feelings.
Family drama bubbles – Harriet’s mum shows up unannounced.
Nolan hides, ghost-style, but it’s comical in a cringey way.
They vow to solve it before Christmas Eve.
Chapter 8: Emotional Peaks
Memory of Harriet’s biggest regret: not standing up to a toxic friend.
She relives the hurt, with Nolan as support.
He shares his regret: not telling his family goodbye.
Tears flow, bonding them deeper.
But the emotional beats feel manipulative, not earned.
In the now, they decorate the tree, all cozy and cute.
Spice level spikes – full-on passion, but it’s more tell than show.
Harriet decides to cut ties with draining people.
Nolan’s fading fast, urgency ramps up.
They brainstorm fixes, but ideas are thin on the ground.
Chapter 9: The Twist Hits
Big reveal: Nolan was meant for Harriet’s ancestor, but a mix-up tied him to her via the shop’s heirlooms.
They travel to the 1800s, witnessing his death linked to her family’s past.
Quick Info Box Feature Details Author Bailey Hannah Genre Contemporary Cowboy Romance Series Wells Ranch, Book 4 (Can read standalone) Tropes Single Mom Romance, Friends to Lovers, He Falls First, Golden Retriever MMC, Found Family, ...
Rachel Gillig's duology finale drags a drugged captive queen through five tournaments thrown by the husband who murdered everyone she loved. 27,000 readers rate it 4.36 — here's what the stars aren't telling you.
It’s dramatic, but the logic’s wonky as a three-legged dog.
Harriet risks everything to “save” him.
Emotions peak with declarations of love.
Back home, his boss intervenes – rules bent, but consequences loom.
Family reconciliation attempt goes south.
Nolan’s humanity solidifies temporarily.
The chapter’s packed, but feels overstuffed.
They prepare for the deadline.
Chapter 10: Racing the Clock
Memories blur as they hunt the key artifact.
Harriet confronts her mum in real time, empowered by Nolan.
It’s cathartic, but dialogue’s stiff.
Nolan’s past fully unveiled – he was a dreamer, lost at sea.
Their love feels fated, but contrived.
Christmas Eve approaches with parties and chaos.
They share intimate moments, but tension’s artificial.
A magical storm brews, threatening separation.
Harriet finds the item: an old locket with his photo.
Cliffhanger vibes as time runs out.
Chapter 11: Resolution and Heartache
They activate the locket, merging past and present.
Nolan gets a choice: stay or go.
He chooses her, but with caveats – he’s sorta human now?
The book’s vague on details, frustrating as hell.
Family mends fences awkwardly.
Romance wraps with a bow, but it’s saccharine.
Epilogue teases the series, with other ghosts.
Harriet’s growth feels half-baked.
Nolan’s arc is better, but still shallow.
Overall, the story’s a mishmash that doesn’t quite gel.
Who Do I Recommend This Book To?
Reckon this one’s for die-hard holiday romance fans who don’t mind a bit of magical fluff and can overlook plot wobbles – think folks who binge Hallmark flicks and love a quick, feel-good escape without much depth.
It’s got appeal for readers craving grumpy-sunshine vibes, where the bloke’s all broody and the sheila’s a ray of sunshine, backed by snippets of emotional family drama that might resonate if you’ve got your own pushover tendencies.
Not for blokes or sheilas who want tight logic in their tales; if you’re after airtight world-building like in proper fantasy yarns, this’ll drive you bonkers with its hand-wavy ghost rules.
Steer clear if you hate insta-love – the chemistry’s forced, no slow burn here, which evidence from reader gripes shows turns off those wanting believable builds.
| Who It’s For | Why | Evidence from Book |
| Holiday Enthusiasts | Cozy Christmas vibes with magic | Endless tree-decorating and peppermint refs, but drags on |
| Romance Lightweights | Quick spicy scenes | Steamy bits pop up fast, though shallow |
| Family Drama Fans | Mum issues explored | Confrontations feel real-ish, but unresolved |
| Who It’s Not For | Logical Plot Seekers | Ghost rules inconsistent, no clear explanations |
| Deep Character Lovers | Surface-level growth | Harriet’s arc repetitive, Nolan’s barely there |
Chuck us a comment below: Who’s your pick for a ghostly romance that actually works? Reckon this one misses the mark too?
Compare with Other Works
Stack this up against “The Dead Romantics” by Ashley Poston, and it’s like comparing a flat beer to a crisp lager – Poston’s got tighter ghost lore and wittier banter, while “Good Spirits” stumbles with vague magic that feels tacked on.
Versus “A Christmas Carol” by Dickens, the original haunt master, this one’s a pale imitation; Dickens nails redemption with sharp social jabs, but Borison’s version waters it down to mushy feels without the bite.
If you’re thinking of “Lovelight Farms” by the same author, that one’s cozier and more grounded – no ghosts, just farm charm that actually sticks, unlike this ethereal flop.
- The Ghost Bride by Yangsze Choo: Choo’s got cultural depth and eerie atmosphere; Borison’s is superficial holiday cheer without the cultural punch.
- Just Like Heaven (film inspo): The movie’s got charm and laughs; this book tries but lands flat with overdone yearning.
- Icebreaker by Hannah Grace: Grace’s got sporty spice and real tension; this one’s all tell, no show.
Table for quick compares:
| Book/Work | Strength Over Good Spirits | Weakness Shared |
| The Dead Romantics | Better ghost mechanics | Both have insta-attraction |
| A Christmas Carol | Deeper themes | Holiday setting overload |
| Lovelight Farms | Grounded romance | Author style repeats |
What d’you reckon – does this stack up to your faves, or nah? Drop a line in the comments, eh?
Why the Magic Falls Flat
Adding this bit ’cause it’s key for punters scratching their heads on the supernatural side.
The ghostly bureaucracy’s a neat idea – receptionists in the afterlife? Bloody ripper concept.
But it fizzles quick, with no rules sticking, making the whole haunt feel like a half-arsed prank.
Evidence? Nolan’s powers flip-flop without reason, leaving you yelling at the page for consistency.
Final Gripes and Why Skip It
Wrapping up, this book’s got heart in spots, but the execution’s as messy as a barbie in the rain.
Plot holes galore, characters that don’t evolve much, and a resolution that ties up too neatly without earning it.
If you’re after a laugh at a bungled ghost tale, maybe give it a burl – but reckon you’ll be left wanting more substance.
Oi, what’s your biggest book pet peeve? Comment below and let’s yarn about better reads!
What if a cosy Colorado B&B turned out to be a snooze-fest of recycled romance tropes, with 7 guests moping about their exes in ways that feel as fresh as last week's vegemite on toast? ...
Imagine being sixteen, seeing visions of God, then getting locked in a stone box for life because a power-hungry bishop decided your divine gifts would make a cracking PR stunt. That's Aleys's reward in Janet ...