The Gift Book Review, Synopsis & Explain: 5 Brutal Plot Holes

2 days ago

Book Axis

21 minutes

The Gift by Freida McFadden takes O. Henry’s classic holiday fable The Gift of the Magi and chucks it straight into a woodchipper of domestic paranoia, financial ruin, and felony burglary. Published in December 2022, this 43-page psychological thriller hooks you with a dark Christmas Eve dilemma: how far will a dead-broke couple go to afford the ultimate festive present—and which one of them just bashed the local antique dealer over the head to get it? Between a blood-stained crowbar hidden in the laundry, a frantic haircut on the dodgy side of town, and a basement finale that flips the marriage upside down, this bite-sized thriller packs maximum holiday chaos into under an hour.

Attribute	Quick Facts & Specs
Title	The Gift: A Psychological Thriller Short Story
Author	Freida McFadden
Publication Date	December 4, 2022
Format & Length	43 Pages (Kindle E-book) / 56 Minutes (Unabridged Audiobook)
Narrator (Audio)	Leslie Howard
Sub-Genre	Holiday Domestic Suspense / Twist Ending Novella
Critique Ratio	70% Veteran Reader Roast / 30% Guilty Pleasure Praise

Outline show

Detailed Summary

Part 1: Broke Pockets and Priceless Heirlooms (Chapters 1 to 3)

Chapter 1 opens on the morning of December 23rd, and our first-person narrator, Jenna, is staring down the barrel of a miserable, broke Christmas. Earlier in the year, her husband Arthur lost his well-paying corporate office job after company downsizing and had to take a low-wage manual labour role at a local hardware store just to keep the lights on.

Jenna reaches into the back of the kitchen pantry, pulls out their emergency savings tin, and tips the coins onto the laminate counter. The grand total comes to $14.72—barely enough for a cheap takeaway lunch, let alone a proper Christmas gift for a bloke who works sixty hours a week in the freezing cold.

Chapter 2 takes us down Main Street as Jenna walks through the biting winter wind toward Goldman’s Antiques. Pressed up against the frosted glass window, she stares at the one thing she wants more than anything in the world for Arthur: a vintage, intricate silver chain-link watch band sitting on a velvet display stand.

Years ago, Arthur inherited a heavy gold pocket-watch face from his late grandfather, Pop-Pop, which has been sitting broken in his top sock drawer because the original strap snapped in half. Jenna swallows her pride, steps inside the musty shop, and asks the sour-faced owner, Mr. Goldman, if he would accept a small deposit or knock the $200 price tag down for Christmas.

Mr. Goldman scoffs in her face, taps the “No Layaway, Cash Only” sign next to the register, and tells her that $200 is already a steal for genuine antique silver. Defeated and burning with humiliation, Jenna walks back out into the snow while catching her reflection in the shop mirror—specifically her waist-length, glossy chestnut hair that reaches all the way down to her hips.

Chapter 3 brings Jenna back to their freezing one-bedroom flat, where the ancient radiator clanks and hisses without pumping out any actual heat. Both she and Arthur have only ever been proud of two physical possessions in their marriage: Pop-Pop’s heirloom gold watch face and Jenna’s cascade of thick brown hair, which Arthur loves brushing every night before bed.

Just after 8:00 PM, the front door clicks open and Arthur steps inside, looking utterly knackered from hauling timber and bags of cement all day. Despite the dark circles under his eyes, he has a weird, secretive smirk plastered across his face and quickly shoves a crumpled white receipt deep into his heavy canvas work coat when he sees Jenna standing in the hallway.

When Jenna asks why he is nearly two hours late from his shift, Arthur feeds her a vague story about stocktake at the hardware store and refuses to meet her eyes. That tiny moment plants the first seed of toxic paranoia in Jenna’s brain: her sweet, honest husband is hiding something big right before Christmas.

The Gift Book Review, Synopsis & Explain: 5 Brutal Plot Holes

Part 2: The Salon Chop and the Crime Scene (Chapters 4 to 6)

Chapter 4 starts at dawn on December 24th, with Jenna wide awake after tossing and turning all night over Arthur’s sketchy behaviour and her pathetic $14.72 budget. Determined not to let Christmas morning be a total bust, she pulls on her thick winter coat, tucks her long hair under a woollen beanie, and heads toward the gritty commercial strip on 4th Street.

She stops outside a neon-lit storefront called Madame Elena’s Wig Emporium, where a faded poster in the window promises instant cash for long, healthy, unbleached human hair. Before she can talk herself out of it, Jenna marches inside, pulls off her beanie, and lets her waist-length hair tumble down in front of the stern proprietor, Madame Elena.

Madame Elena runs her calloused fingers through the strands, clicks her tongue, and offers $180, which Jenna fiercely negotiates up to $210 so she can cover the sales tax at Goldman’s Antiques. Ten minutes later, the cold steel shears slice straight through her ponytail at the nape of her neck, leaving Jenna with a jagged, boyish pixie crop and eleven crisp bills in her shaking hand.

Chapter 5 follows a freezing-earred Jenna as she practically sprints back toward Main Street, clutching the $210 in her coat pocket like a winning lottery ticket. As she turns the corner near Goldman’s Antiques, however, her celebration comes to a screeching halt: the street is blocked off by two squad cars, flashing blue-and-red sirens, and yellow police crime scene tape.

The front display window of Goldman’s Antiques has been smashed to smithereens, glass glittering across the icy footpath. Standing near the bakery next door, local gossip Mrs. Higgins tells Jenna that someone broke into the shop around 7:00 PM the night before, shoved poor old Mr. Goldman into a display cabinet when he tried to stop them, and bolted with thousands of dollars in vintage jewellery—including the silver watch band from the front window.

Jenna’s blood runs ice-cold as her brain replays the previous evening in slow motion. Arthur hadn’t come home until 8:15 PM, his knuckles were scraped raw, and he had been acting dodgier than a two-dollar watch all night.

Chapter 6 sees Jenna backing slowly away from the police cruisers before the uniforms can ask why she’s staring so hard at the smashed display case. Still desperate to give Arthur his gift—and now desperate to pretend everything is normal—she remembers spotting a nearly identical vintage silver watch strap a month ago at Miller’s Pawn & Loan over on the east side of town.

She catches two city buses across town through a worsening blizzard, bursts into Miller’s Pawn & Loan, and breathes a massive sigh of relief when she spots the silver chain strap still sitting in the cabinet. She slaps $200 cash onto the counter, pockets her receipt, and spends the entire forty-minute bus ride home sweating bullets over whether she is married to an armed robber.

Part 3: Blood on the Knuckles and the Pawn Ticket (Chapters 7 to 9)

Chapter 7 cranks up the domestic claustrophobia inside their tiny apartment on Christmas Eve afternoon. Jenna refuses to take off her thick knitted beanie indoors, telling herself she doesn’t want to ruin the surprise of her sacrifice before Arthur opens his present—though the real mood in the flat feels more like an interrogation room than a holiday celebration.

While Arthur is in the shower washing off the grime from his half-day shift at the hardware store, Jenna walks into the bedroom and spots his heavy canvas work jacket draped over a chair. She picks it up to hang it in the closet, and the coat weighs a ton; something solid and metallic bangs sharply against her shin through the fabric.

Heart hammering against her ribs, Jenna unzips the deep interior lining pocket and pulls out a heavy iron crowbar with dark, dried smudges near the pried end and a tiny glint of crushed glass stuck in the groove. Seconds later, the bathroom door clicks open, and Jenna shoves the crowbar back into the coat just as Arthur walks out in his towel, smiling warmly and asking what’s for dinner.

Chapter 8 flips the narrative coin completely, shifting into Arthur’s point of view for a flashback covering December 22nd and December 23rd. Right away, we discover that Arthur isn’t some violent criminal mastermind; he is just a hopelessly devoted husband who feels like an absolute failure for letting their bank account hit rock bottom.

Back in autumn, while walking past a boutique called Luxe & Lace, Jenna had stopped dead in her tracks to admire a set of genuine tortoiseshell hair combs inlaid with tiny sparkling crystals. They were priced at $180, and Jenna had sighed and walked away, saying she would never waste money like that while they were struggling to pay rent.

Chapter 9 explains every single suspicious clue Jenna spent the last four chapters panicking over. On the evening of December 23rd—around the exact same time Goldman’s Antiques was getting smashed and grabbed—Arthur walked into Miller’s Pawn & Loan and sold Pop-Pop’s solid gold pocket-watch face to the pawnbroker for $185 cash.

The crumpled paper he hid in his pocket in Chapter 3 wasn’t a clue to a heist; it was the pawn shop bill of sale and the boutique receipt for Jenna’s tortoiseshell combs. And what about the scraped knuckles and the heavy iron crowbar with glass on it in Chapter 7?

His hardware store boss, Big Dave, had paid Arthur an extra $20 cash off the books after closing time to pry open a rusted, jammed delivery bay window and door frame that had frozen shut in the blizzard. Arthur kept the crowbar in his coat because Big Dave told him to hang onto it to fix his own jammed apartment radiator over the Christmas break.

Part 4: The Magi Exchange and the Basement Shocker (Chapters 10 to 13)

Chapter 10 brings the narrative back to Jenna’s perspective after a tense Christmas Eve pasta dinner, as the couple sits cross-legged beside their tiny plastic tabletop tree. Snow rattles against the windowpane while Arthur reaches behind the sofa cushions and hands Jenna a small, neatly wrapped square box with a gold ribbon.

Jenna’s hands tremble as she peels back the wrapping paper and lifts the lid of the velvet jeweller’s box. Sitting on the satin cushion are the exact tortoiseshell hair combs from Luxe & Lace—the ones designed specifically to hold up the thick, waist-length chestnut hair currently sitting in a bin bag at Madame Elena’s Wig Emporium.

Chapter 11 delivers the gut-punch emotional payoff before the thriller twist kicks the door down. With tears spilling down her cheeks, Jenna reaches up, grips the edge of her knitted beanie, and slowly pulls it off her head to reveal her ragged, ultra-short haircut.

Arthur stares at her shorn head in stunned silence, his mind struggling to process where three feet of chestnut hair disappeared to over the last twelve hours. Jenna forces a tearful smile, tells him her hair grows fast anyway, and hands him the long, flat package wrapped in red tissue paper.

Chapter 12 watches Arthur tear open the package to find the gleaming vintage silver watch strap—the exact piece he needed to finally wear Pop-Pop’s heirloom watch on his wrist. Instead of cheering, Arthur drops his head back against the sofa and lets out a ragged, hysterical laugh before confessing that he pawned Pop-Pop’s gold watch face the night before to buy her hair combs.

He pulls her into a tight embrace, telling her they are a pair of idiots who love each other too much, and promises they will save up to buy the watch back in the new year.On the surface, it reads like a sweet, slightly dramatic modern remake of O. Henry’s classic tale.

Chapter 13 (The Epilogue) jumps forward to December 27th, while Arthur is back pulling a ten-hour shift at the hardware store and Jenna heads down to the concrete basement storage lockers to put away their plastic Christmas tree. She unlocks their padlock, steps past the dusty cardboard boxes, and kneels in front of an old winter boot box hidden behind a stack of paint tins on her shelf.

Jenna lifts the cardboard lid, revealing a black wool ski mask, a pair of heavy leather gardening gloves, three trays of stolen antique diamond rings, and the original silver watch band from Goldman’s Antiques—still strapped to its smashed black velvet display stand. A wicked, calculating smile spreads across Jenna’s face as the real timeline finally clicks into place.

On the night of December 23rd, Jenna was the one who smashed the window of Goldman’s Antiques with a brick, shoved Mr. Goldman to the floor, and looted the display cases so they wouldn’t be broke anymore. During the scuffle, however, her ski mask snagged and slipped up at the back, allowing Mr. Goldman and a passing witness to spot a woman with waist-length chestnut hair fleeing down the alley.

Jenna didn’t chop her hair off at Madame Elena’s on Christmas Eve morning out of pure romantic sacrifice for Arthur. She chopped her hair off to destroy the physical evidence connecting her to a violent felony, used the $210 hair money to buy a second, legal watch strap at the pawn shop so she had a clean receipt if the cops came knocking, and mentally framed her own husband just in case she needed a scapegoat!

Chapter Block	POV Character	Core Plot Action	The Hidden Reality
Chapters 1–3	Jenna	Counts $14.72; begs Mr. Goldman for a discount; suspects Arthur coming home late.	Jenna is setting up the timeline right before she commits a violent robbery.
Chapters 4–6	Jenna	Sells her hair for $210; sees cops at Goldman’s; buys a strap at Miller’s Pawn.	She cut her hair to dodge police eye-witness descriptions, not for love.
Chapters 7–9	Jenna / Arthur	Jenna finds a crowbar in Arthur’s coat; Arthur reveals he pawned Pop-Pop’s watch.	Arthur is 100% innocent and actually sacrificed his only family heirloom.
Chapters 10–13	Jenna	Comb and strap exchanged; Epilogue shows stolen loot in Jenna’s basement box.	Jenna is a cold-blooded thief sitting on thousands in stolen diamonds.

Characters?

Jenna

Jenna is the first-person narrator and the textbook definition of a manipulative sociopath disguised as a struggling housewife. Throughout the first twelve chapters, she paints herself as a stressed, self-sacrificing spouse who only wants to give her hard-working husband a decent Christmas, while secretly sitting on a stash of stolen jewellery from an elderly man she assaulted.

From a literary critique standpoint, Jenna is one of Freida McFadden’s most frustrating narrators because she actively lies to the reader inside her own private thoughts. In Chapter 5 and Chapter 7, she has no audience around her, yet she thinks to herself, “Wait, did Arthur rob Goldman’s Antiques?”—even though she is the one who robbed the shop twelve hours earlier!

Arthur

Arthur is the emotional punching bag of the story—a loyal, blue-collar husband who genuinely embodies the spirit of O. Henry’s original story. Despite losing his corporate career and busting his knuckles at a hardware store in sub-zero weather, his only priority is putting a smile on his wife’s face by selling his dead grandfather’s watch.

While he is thoroughly likeable, he also suffers from terminal “Thriller Husband Blindness.” The bloke lives in a tiny one-bedroom apartment with a woman who commits armed robbery, hides bags of stolen diamonds in the basement, and chops off three feet of hair overnight, yet he never suspects a single thing.

Mr. Goldman

Mr. Goldman is the cantankerous, elderly owner of Goldman’s Antiques on Main Street. In Chapter 2, he acts like a budget Ebenezer Scrooge by mocking Jenna’s empty wallet, which the narrative uses as a flimsy excuse to make us feel less guilty when Jenna smashes his shop window and shoves him into a cabinet later that night.

Madame Elena

Madame Elena is the shrewd, no-nonsense owner of Madame Elena’s Wig Emporium on 4th Street. She provides the transactional turning point in Chapter 4, paying Jenna $210 cash for her virgin chestnut hair and inadvertently handing Jenna the ultimate alibi to fool both her husband and the local police department.

Big Dave

Big Dave is Arthur’s gruff manager at the local hardware store who keeps Arthur back after hours on December 23rd to pry open a frozen loading dock door. He never speaks a line of dialogue on the page, existing purely as a mechanical plot device to put a bloody knuckle and an iron crowbar into Arthur’s coat pocket.

Mrs. Higgins

Mrs. Higgins is the nosy local bystander outside the bakery on Main Street in Chapter 5 who fills Jenna in on the police investigation at Goldman’s Antiques. In retrospect, Jenna only talks to Mrs. Higgins to fish for information and find out whether Mr. Goldman survived the assault and what description he gave the cops.

Pop-Pop

Pop-Pop is Arthur’s deceased grandfather who left behind the heirloom gold pocket watch. Even though he is dead before page one, his watch serves as the central MacGuffin that exposes the massive moral gap between Arthur’s genuine sacrifice and Jenna’s criminal cover-up.

Character Name	Narrative Role	Key Action	Moral Alignment
Jenna	Unreliable Narrator / Wife	Robs Goldman’s Antiques; chops hair to destroy evidence.	Chaotic Evil (Lies in her own monologue)
Arthur	Devoted Husband	Pawns his grandfather’s gold watch for $185 to buy hair combs.	Lawful Good (Pure, gullible bloke)
Mr. Goldman	Antique Dealer	Refuses to give a discount; gets assaulted during the break-in.	Neutral Grumpy (Didn’t deserve a concussion)
Madame Elena	Wig Shop Proprietor	Buys Jenna’s waist-length hair for $210 cash.	True Neutral (Strictly business)
Big Dave	Hardware Store Boss	Pays Arthur $20 to unjam a frozen loading bay with a crowbar.	Neutral Plot Device (Red herring supplier)
Mrs. Higgins	Main Street Gossip	Leaks crime scene details outside the police cordon.	Chaotic Nosy (Town broadcaster)
Pop-Pop	Deceased Grandfather	Bequeathed the broken gold pocket watch to Arthur.	Posthumous Catalyst

Veteran Reader Critique: Why the Roast Beats the Praise (70% Criticism vs. 30% Praise)

If you have read more than a dozen psychological thrillers in your life, The Gift reads less like a masterclass in suspense and more like a cheeky literary prank pulled off over a long weekend. Let’s break down what actually works before we tear into the five massive flaws that hold this story back.

What Earns a Pass (The 30% Praise)

Pacing That Wastes Zero Time: At 43 pages, there is zero filler. You don’t have to slog through three chapters about what the characters ate for breakfast—you are in and out in 45 minutes flat.
Subverting a Holiday Classic: Taking O. Henry’s wholesome The Gift of the Magi—a story every kid is forced to read in high school—and turning Della into a violent B&E merchant with a stash of hot diamonds is darkly hilarious.
Bite-Sized Accessibility: For commuters, busy shift workers, or readers in a massive book slump, the short chapters and basic vocabulary make it effortlessly readable on a phone screen.

The 5 Brutal Flaws That Ruin the Logic (The 70% Roast)

Narrator Perjury (The Ultimate Thriller Cheat): In a first-person narrative ("I"), a narrator can omit facts, spin the truth, or rationalize bad behaviour—like Agatha Christie did brilliantly in The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. What a first-person narrator cannot logically do is look at a crime scene they committed and think privately to themselves, “Gosh, I wonder if my husband Arthur did this?” Who is Jenna putting on an act for inside her own skull? Unless she has multiple personalities (which she doesn’t), Freida McFadden simply cheats the reader to hide the twist.
The Double Watch Strap Stupidity: Think about the economics of Chapter 6 and Chapter 13 for five seconds. Jenna already stole the original silver watch band from Goldman’s Antiques on the night of December 23rd. Then, on December 24th, she sells her hair for $210 and spends $200 buying a second watch band at a pawn shop. Why? Even if she needed to cut her hair to change her appearance for the cops, she already had a watch band in the basement! All she had to do was pocket the $210 hair cash, wrap up the stolen watch band (after peeling off the Goldman’s price tag), and tell Arthur she bought it at a pawn shop with her hair money. Blowing $200 on a duplicate strap when they only have $14.72 in the bank is peak stupidity.
The Pawn Shop Coincidence: What are the actual statistical odds that Arthur pawns his grandfather’s watch at Miller’s Pawn & Loan on the night of December 23rd, and Jenna walks into that exact same pawn shop the next morning to buy a watch strap, without either of them noticing the watch face sitting in the case or the pawnbroker recognizing the last name?
Zero Psychological Transition: For twelve chapters, Jenna’s internal voice is warm, anxious, empathetic, and deeply in love with her husband. Then, in the final two pages of the Epilogue, she morphs into a cartoon villain smirking over a box of stolen diamonds and casually shrugging off assaulting an elderly shopkeeper. There is zero character consistency between Chapters 1–12 Jenna and Chapter 13 Jenna.
90% Borrowed Plot Architecture: Aside from the antique shop break-in tacked onto the edges, almost every structural beat—the $14 budget, the heirloom watch, the long hair, the wig shop negotiation, the tortoiseshell combs, and the Christmas Eve reveal—is lifted straight out of O. Henry’s 1905 public-domain short story.

Compare with Other Works

To see where The Gift sits in the broader thriller landscape—and inside Freida McFadden’s own bibliography—check out how it compares to similar titles:

Title	Author	Length	Core Hook / Connection	How It Compares to The Gift
The Gift (2022)	Freida McFadden	43 Pages	Dark thriller parody/retelling of The Gift of the Magi.	Fast and cheeky, but relies on dishonest first-person narration to hide its twist.
The Gift of the Magi (1905)	O. Henry	~6 Pages	The original story of Jim and Della selling their prized possessions.	100x more emotionally resonant and doesn’t require anyone to commit a felony.
The Widow’s Husband’s Secret Lie (2024)	Freida McFadden	58 Pages	Intentional parody novella mocking domestic thriller clichés.	Way better executed because it openly embraces being a comedy rather than faking seriousness.
The Wife Upstairs (2020)	Freida McFadden	308 Pages	Full-length domestic thriller with an unreliable marriage dynamic.	Gives the domestic paranoia room to build properly instead of cramming it into 40 pages.
The Housemaid (2022)	Freida McFadden	336 Pages	Blockbuster thriller with a mid-book POV switch that reframes everything.	Shows how McFadden can pull off a proper, fair-play POV twist when she has 300+ pages.

Achievements & Hard Commercial Numbers

Critics and veteran thriller readers might tear the plot logic to shreds, but commercially, The Gift is a juggernaut in the short-form digital publishing world. Here are the concrete numbers the novella has racked up across international platforms:

Metric Category	Verified Milestone / Figure	Platform / Context
Goodreads Ratings Count	138,000+ Total Ratings	Massive volume for a 43-page seasonal e-book exclusive.
Goodreads Written Reviews	8,800+ User Reviews	High engagement driven by polarized reactions to the Epilogue twist.
Goodreads Average Score	3.79 / 5.0 Stars	Lower than her full-length novels (The Housemaid sits at 4.30+), reflecting twist backlash.
Amazon Global Ratings	29,500+ Verified Ratings	Holds a 4.1 / 5.0 Star average across Amazon US, UK, and Australia.
Amazon Chart Peaks	#1 Bestseller in 3 Categories	Hit #1 in 90-Minute Mystery & Thriller Short Reads, Holiday Fiction, and Single-Sitting Reads.
Kindle Unlimited (KENP)	15+ Million Pages Read	Consistently surges into the Top 50 Kindle Unlimited borrows every December since 2022.
Social Media Reach	18+ Million Combined Views	Featured heavily across BookTok (`#FreidaMcFadden`, `#TheGiftBook`) and Bookstagram holiday lists.

Frequently Asked Questions (AEO Quick-Answer Guide)

How many chapters are in The Gift by Freida McFadden?

The Gift contains 12 main chapters plus an Epilogue (Chapter 13), spanning 43 pages in the standard Kindle digital edition and running 56 minutes in the unabridged audiobook version.

What is the plot twist at the end of The Gift by Freida McFadden?

While the entire story tricks you into suspecting the husband (Arthur) of robbing Goldman’s Antiques, the Epilogue reveals that the narrator (Jenna) actually robbed the store herself. She only cut and sold her long chestnut hair because witnesses saw a long-haired woman fleeing the crime scene, allowing her to destroy the evidence and frame her haircut as a romantic Christmas sacrifice.

Is The Gift by Freida McFadden worth reading?

If you have Kindle Unlimited and want a fast, darkly comedic 45-minute holiday read, it is worth a quick look. However, if you hate unreliable narrators who blatantly lie inside their own internal thoughts or dislike heavy rehashes of The Gift of the Magi, you should skip it and read The Housemaid instead.

Sound Off Below: Clever Christmas Twist or Total Rip-Off?

Now it is over to you, legends! When you hit that basement reveal in the Epilogue, did you let out a cheeky laugh at how ruthless Jenna was, or did you want to launch your Kindle across the room because she spent twelve chapters lying to herself in her own head?

More importantly, if you were Arthur and you stumbled across that boot box full of stolen diamonds and a ski mask on Boxing Day, are you calling the cops on your missus or quietly booking two tickets to Fiji? Drop your rating out of 10 and your wildest take in the comments below—let’s argue it out!

← Previous reviewThe Last King of Faerie Review, Synopsis & 7 Secrets Explained Next review →Peculiar Stars Review, Synopsis & Explain: 543 Brutal Days